AN - 578/2021: Difference between revisions

From GDPRhub
(Created page with "{{DPAdecisionBOX |Jurisdiction=Spain |DPA-BG-Color=background-color:#ffffff; |DPAlogo=LogoES.jpg |DPA_Abbrevation=AEPD |DPA_With_Country=AEPD (Spain) |Case_Number_Name=SAN 5...")
 
Line 50: Line 50:
Canary Islands Car, S.L., a car rental company, filed an appeal with the National Audience against the resolution number PS/00385/2018  issued by the Spanish Data Protection Authority (AEPD) in which a fine of €25,000 was imposed on them for breaching the principle of Accuracy set out in Article 5(1)(d) GDPR. The National Audience dismissed the appeal and declared the resolution in accordance with the law.  
Canary Islands Car, S.L., a car rental company, filed an appeal with the National Audience against the resolution number PS/00385/2018  issued by the Spanish Data Protection Authority (AEPD) in which a fine of €25,000 was imposed on them for breaching the principle of Accuracy set out in Article 5(1)(d) GDPR. The National Audience dismissed the appeal and declared the resolution in accordance with the law.  


== English Summary ==
==English Summary==


=== Facts ===
===Facts===
The facts of resolution PS/ 00385/2018 are that due to two customers having the same name and failure to verify customer details, Canary Islands Car, S.L. incorrectly used the information of customer A to create a car rental contract for customer B, who then committed a traffic offence. Subsequently, the details of customer A were incorrectly passed on to the General direction of traffic (DGT).  
The facts of resolution PS/ 00385/2018 are that due to two customers having the same name and failure to verify customer details, Canary Islands Car, S.L. incorrectly used the information of customer A to create a car rental contract for customer B, who then committed a traffic offence. Subsequently, the details of customer A were incorrectly passed on to the General direction of traffic (DGT).  


Once DGT contacted the complainant, she/he realised that the contract that Canary Islands Cars provided to the DGT with the purposes of issuing the sanction was dissimilar to the one she/he had initially signed. Based on this mismatch of information, the complainant appealed the sanction upon receiving it.  
Once the DGT contacted the complainant, she/he realised that the contract that Canary Island Cars provided to the DGT for the purposes of issuing the fine was dissimilar to the one she/he had initially signed. Based on the mismatch of information, the complainant appealed the fine upon receiving it.  


The AEPD noted the following in resolution PS/ 00385/2018:
The AEPD noted the following in resolution PS/ 00385/2018:


"Considering that there may be similar names and surnames, the defendant has elements to verify identity by national ID (DNI), number that matches that of the driving licence, customer number or printing of the copy of the contract, among others, although these verifications are carried out by the employees, it should be noted that in this case they were not carried out, if any of the three elements had been verified, the defect could have been detected in its origin. In other words, the identification document must be required at the right time to make it effective to measure”.
"Knowing that there may be different names and surnames, the defendant has elements to verify identity by national ID (DNI), number that matches that of the driving licence, customer number or printing of the copy of the contract, among others, although these verifications are carried out by the employees, it should be noted that in this case they were not carried out, if any of the three elements had been verified, the defect could have been detected in its origin. In other words, the identification document must be required at the right time to make it effective to measure”.


In the appeal to this resolution, Canary Islands Cars argued that there had been not a breach of the accuracy principle because the name associated was correct. The car rental company alleged that this was simple human error and a fortuitous event.  It also argued that the sanction imposed was disproportionate.
In the appeal to this resolution, Canary Islands Cars argued that the accuracy principle had not been breached because the associated name was correct. The car rental company alleged that this was a human error and a fortuitous event.  It also argued that the sanction imposed was disproportionate.




=== Dispute ===
===Dispute===
Has the resolution of the AEPD been decided in error? Should the appeal be allowed for Canary Island Cars, S.L.?
Has the resolution of the AEPD been decided in error? Should the appeal be allowed for Canary Island Cars, S.L.?


=== Holding ===
===Holding===
The National Audience dismissed the appeal after analising the arguments of the appellant and declared that the resolution was in accordance with the law with express imposition of payments of procedural costs on the appellant.  
When analising the appellant's arguments, the National Audience noted "The mere coincidence of name and surname does not justify the creating of the car rental contract with the data of another person... especially when you have the person in front, to whom the car is handed over and several people or phases intervene: preparation of the contract, data collection and delivery-verification of the vehicle, delivery of a copy of the contract, payment, procedures in all of which must verify the identity of the contracting party and in this case no diligence is accredited".  


== Comment ==
The National Audience dismissed the appeal and declared that the resolution was in accordance with the law with express imposition of payments of procedural costs on the appellant.
 
==Comment==
''Share your comments here!''
''Share your comments here!''


== Further Resources ==
==Further Resources==
''Share blogs or news articles here!''
''Share blogs or news articles here!''


== English Machine Translation of the Decision ==
==English Machine Translation of the Decision==
The decision below is a machine translation of the Spanish original. Please refer to the Spanish original for more details.
The decision below is a machine translation of the Spanish original. Please refer to the Spanish original for more details.


Revision as of 22:04, 8 April 2021

AEPD - SAN 578/2021
LogoES.jpg
Authority: AEPD (Spain)
Jurisdiction: Spain
Relevant Law: Article 5(1)(d) GDPR
Type: Other
Outcome: n/a
Started:
Decided: 26.02.2021
Published:
Fine: None
Parties: Canary Island Cars, S.L.
National Case Number/Name: SAN 578/2021
European Case Law Identifier: ECLI:ES:AN:2021:578
Appeal: Appealed - Overturned
Original Language(s): Spanish
Original Source: Consejo General del Poder Judicial (in ES)
Initial Contributor: Paola L.

Canary Islands Car, S.L., a car rental company, filed an appeal with the National Audience against the resolution number PS/00385/2018 issued by the Spanish Data Protection Authority (AEPD) in which a fine of €25,000 was imposed on them for breaching the principle of Accuracy set out in Article 5(1)(d) GDPR. The National Audience dismissed the appeal and declared the resolution in accordance with the law.

English Summary

Facts

The facts of resolution PS/ 00385/2018 are that due to two customers having the same name and failure to verify customer details, Canary Islands Car, S.L. incorrectly used the information of customer A to create a car rental contract for customer B, who then committed a traffic offence. Subsequently, the details of customer A were incorrectly passed on to the General direction of traffic (DGT).

Once the DGT contacted the complainant, she/he realised that the contract that Canary Island Cars provided to the DGT for the purposes of issuing the fine was dissimilar to the one she/he had initially signed. Based on the mismatch of information, the complainant appealed the fine upon receiving it.

The AEPD noted the following in resolution PS/ 00385/2018:

"Knowing that there may be different names and surnames, the defendant has elements to verify identity by national ID (DNI), number that matches that of the driving licence, customer number or printing of the copy of the contract, among others, although these verifications are carried out by the employees, it should be noted that in this case they were not carried out, if any of the three elements had been verified, the defect could have been detected in its origin. In other words, the identification document must be required at the right time to make it effective to measure”.

In the appeal to this resolution, Canary Islands Cars argued that the accuracy principle had not been breached because the associated name was correct. The car rental company alleged that this was a human error and a fortuitous event. It also argued that the sanction imposed was disproportionate.


Dispute

Has the resolution of the AEPD been decided in error? Should the appeal be allowed for Canary Island Cars, S.L.?

Holding

When analising the appellant's arguments, the National Audience noted "The mere coincidence of name and surname does not justify the creating of the car rental contract with the data of another person... especially when you have the person in front, to whom the car is handed over and several people or phases intervene: preparation of the contract, data collection and delivery-verification of the vehicle, delivery of a copy of the contract, payment, procedures in all of which must verify the identity of the contracting party and in this case no diligence is accredited".

The National Audience dismissed the appeal and declared that the resolution was in accordance with the law with express imposition of payments of procedural costs on the appellant.

Comment

Share your comments here!

Further Resources

Share blogs or news articles here!

English Machine Translation of the Decision

The decision below is a machine translation of the Spanish original. Please refer to the Spanish original for more details. 

<!DOCTYPE html><html lang="es"><head><title>General Council of the Judiciary: Content search engine </title><meta http-equiv="Expires" content="-1" /><meta http-equiv="Pragma" content="no-cache" /><meta http-equiv="Cache-Control" content="no-cache" /><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"/><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"/><link rel="shortcut icon" href="/search/favicon.png" type="image/x-icon"/><link href='/search/css/font-roboto.css' rel='stylesheet' type='text/css'><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/jquery-ui.min.css" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/normalize.css" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/bootstrap.min.css" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/bootstrap-select.min.css" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/bootstrap-datetimepicker.min.css" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/font-awesome.min.css"/><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/bootstrap-multiselect.css"/><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/common-styles.css?guid=202103311549" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/styles.css?guid=202103311549" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/captcha.css?guid=202103311549"/><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/lineajur.css?guid=202103311549" /><!--  ayudas --><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/help.css?guid=202103311549" /><link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="all" href="/search/css/responsive.css?guid=202103311549" /><!--[if IE 7]>
		  <link rel="stylesheet" href="/search/css/bootstrap-ie7.css" />
		  <link rel="stylesheet" href="/search/css/ie7-styles.css" />
		  <link rel="stylesheet" href="/search/css/font-awesome-ie7.min.css" />
		<![endif]--><!-- librerias externas --><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/html5shiv.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/respond.min.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/moment.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/locale/es.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/locale/gl.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/locale/ca.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/locale/eu.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/jquery-1.11.2.min.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/jquery-ui.min.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/bootstrap.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/bootstrap-select.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/bootstrap-datetimepicker.min.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/jquery.nicescroll.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/clipboard.min.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/jquery.fileDownload.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/bootstrap-multiselect.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/webspeech.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script type="text/javascript" language="JavaScript">
		<!-- 

    		var contextPath = "/search/";
    		var mobile = false;
   			var startParam = "";
			var seccionParam = "";
			var institucionTParam= "";
			var institucionLParam = "";
			var jurisdiccionParam = "";
    		
    		
	            $(document).ready(function(){
	                openDocumentFromLink();
	            });
	        
			
		-->
		</script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/cookies.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/localizaciones.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/form-components.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/common-scripts.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/jurisprudencia.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/functions.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><!-- autocomplete --><script src="/search/js/autocompleterLocal_ponentesAN.js" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/autocompleterLocal_materiasleg.js" type="text/javascript"></script></head><body class="publico AN " data-tab="AN"><section id="main-container" ><!-- header start --><header class="header"><div class="hidden" id="documentFromLink" data-action="accessToPDF" data-databasematch="AN" data-reference="52c2d7a2a876c5d9"  data-encode=true data-optimize=20210325></div><div class="container-fluid"><div class="row"><div id="appname" class="sidebar topsidebar"><h1> CENDOJ</h1><h2 class="hidden-xs"> Center<br/> Judicial Documentation </h2></div><!-- #appname --><div class="main-header"><div class="row"><div class="pull-right lang-selection"><ul class="hidden"><li data-lang="ca"> <a href="#">cat</a> </li><li data-lang="gl"><span class="separator"> </span> <a href="#">ga</a> </li><li data-lang="eu"><span class="separator"> </span> <a href="#">eusk</a></li></ul></div><!-- .lang-selection --><div class="pull-right utils"><ul><li class="config"> <span id="lnchconfignovedades" data-interfaz="AN" data-a="confignovedades" data-toggle="popover" data-placement="bottom" aria-describedby="confignovedadespopover"><a href="#" class="tooltips"  data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Nuevas funcionalidades"><img src="/search/img/novedades.png"/></a><span id="confignovedades_count" class="badge"></span></span></li><li class="private"> <a href="/search/alerts/" target="_blank" class="tooltips" data-placement="bottom" title="Manage your alerts"><i class="fa fa-user"> </i></a></li><li class="help"><a href="#" class="tooltips" data-toggle="tooltip" data-interfaz="AN" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Ayuda"><i class="fa fa-question-circle"> </i></a></li></ul></div><!-- .pull-right --><!--  popovers --><div class="hidden"><div id="confignovedades"><div id="layoutconfignovedades"><div class="desc"> New features </div><!-- .desc --><div id="confignovedadescontent"><ul class="cnfnovedadeslist"></ul></div><!-- .row  --></div></div><!-- #confignovedades--></div><!-- .hidden --><div class="pull-right statstop hidden-sm hidden-md hidden-lg"> <a class="tooltips" data-placement="bottom" title="Statistics service" href="/search/estadisticas/" target="_blank"><img src="/search/img/statstop.png"/></a> </div></div><!-- .row --><div class="row principal"><div class="hidden-xs pull-left logo"><div id="cdpj" class="hidden-sm pull-left nopad"> tip<br/> General of the<br/> Power of attorney </div><div class="pull-left"><img src="/search/img/logo.png" alt="CENDOJ"/></div></div><!-- .logo --><div class="pull-right portal   "><h2> Supreme court<br/> National audience<br/> high Court of Justice<br/> Provincial Court<br/> Military and One-Person Courts</h2></div><div class="pull-right statslink hidden-xs"> <a href="/search/estadisticas/" target="_blank"><img src="/search/img/statslnk.png"/><span>Statistics service</span></a> </div></div><!-- .row --></div><!-- .main-header --></div><!-- .row --></div><!-- .container-fluid --></header><!-- header end --><div class="container-fluid"><div class="row"><!--main content start--><section id="main-content" class="main-content"><!-- tab jurisprudencia start --><section id="jurisprudencia" class="bbtabcontent active"><ol class="breadcrumb hidden"><li data-subtab="search" class="active on"> <a href="#">Seeker</a></li><li data-subtab="results" class=""> <a href="#">Results</a></li><li data-subtab="content"> <a href="#">Document</a> </li></ol><!-- .breadcrumb --><div id="jurisprudenciasearch" class="clearfix search bbsubtabcontent active"><!-- menu xs --><div class="visible-xs"><div class="last50select dropdown"><a data-toggle="dropdown" class="dropdown-toggle" href="#"><i class="fa fa-clock-o"> </i>Latest Resolutions<span class="caret pull-right"></span></a> <div class="dropdown-menu"><ul class="last50options" role="menu"><li data-tab="CIVIL" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">CIVIL</a></li><li data-tab="PENAL" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">PENAL</a></li><li data-tab="contencioso" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">CONTENTIOUS</a> </li><li data-tab="contencioso" class="dropdown-last50sections"><ul><li data-sec="1" data-tab="CONTENCIOSO" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">Sec. 1</a></li><li data-sec="2" data-tab="CONTENCIOSO" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">Sec. 2</a></li><li data-sec="3" data-tab="CONTENCIOSO" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">Sec. 3</a></li><li data-sec="4" data-tab="CONTENCIOSO" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">Sec. 4</a></li><li data-sec="5" data-tab="CONTENCIOSO" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">Sec. 5</a></li></ul></li><li data-tab="SOCIAL" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">SOCIAL</a></li><li data-tab="MILITAR" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">MILITARY</a></li><li data-tab="ESPECIAL" class="dropdown-lastTS"> <a href="#">SPECIAL</a> </li></ul></div><!-- .dropdown-menu --></div><!-- .navselect.dropdown --></div><!-- .row --><!-- menu xs end --><div id="mainjurisprudenciasearch" class=""><div id="jurformsearch" class="searchform principal"><form id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia" class="form-horizontal" action="search.action"><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_action" name="action" value="query"/><input type="hidden" class="temporal" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_lastsentences" name="lastsentences" value=""/><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_databasematch" name="databasematch" value="AN"/><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ANYO" name="ANYO" value=""/><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_start" name="start" value="1"/><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_maxresults" name="maxresults" value=""/><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_page" name="page" value=""/><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ID_NORMA" name="ID_NORMA" value="" /><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ARTICULO" name="ARTICULO" value="" /><input type="hidden" id="org" name="org" value="" /><input type="hidden" id="ccaa" name="ccaa" value="" /><input type="hidden" class="temporal" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_land" name="land" value="" /><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_INSTITUCIONES" name="TIPOINTERES_INSTITUCIONES" value="" /><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_INSTITUCION" name="INSTITUCION" value="" /><!-- temas --><input type="hidden" class="temporal" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_landing" name="landing" value=""/><input type="hidden" class="temporal" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_landingtype" name="landingtype" value=""/><!-- en instituciones --><!-- bloque 1 start --><div class="form-big row"><div class="form-row row"><a id="micro" class="micro tooltips" title="Activate voice input" href="#" data-container="body" data-html="true" data-tab="jurisprudencia" style="display:none;"
							data-template='<div class="tooltip speech" role="tooltip"><div class="tooltip-arrow"></div><div class="tooltip-inner"></div></div>'><i class="fa fa-microphone"></i></a> <div class="col-xs-12"><i class="fa fa-search hidden-xs"></i><input type="text" name="TEXT" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TEXT" autofocus class="form-control input-sm autocomplete addoperators showtooltip" 
							placeholder="Búsqueda por texto libre" value=""/><div class="hidden-xs operators col-sm-7 nopad" data-form="frmBusquedajurisprudencia"> <a href="#" data-operator="Y">AND</a> <span class="separator"> </span> <a href="#" data-operator="O">OR</a> <span class="separator"> </span> <a href="#" data-operator="NO">No</a> <span class="separator"> </span> <a href="#" data-operator="PROX">Next</a> </div><!-- .operators --></div><!-- .col-sm-9 --></div><!-- .form-row --></div><!-- .form-big --><!-- bloque 1 end --><div class="line"></div><!-- bloque 2 start --><div class="form-group row"><div class="form-row row"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_JURISDICCION" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Jurisdiction</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 fit"><select id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_JURISDICCION" name="JURISDICCION" class="multiselect form-control"  multiple="multiple"><option value="CIVIL" > Civil</option><option value="PENAL" > Penal</option><option value="CONTENCIOSO" > Contentious</option><option value="SOCIAL" > Social</option><option value="MILITAR" > Military</option><option value="ESPECIAL" > Special</option></select></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_SUBTIPORESOLUCION" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Type res.</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 fit"><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPORESOLUCION" name="TIPORESOLUCION" value=""/><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_SUBTIPORESOLUCION" name="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" value=""/><div class="btn-group "> <button data-toggle="dropdown" id="SUBTIPORESOLUCIONmultiselec" data-placement="bottom" class="multiselect tooltips dropdown-toggle btn btn-default tooltips clearable" type="button" title="All"><span class="multiselect-selected-text">All</span><b class="caret"></b></button> <ul id="SUBTIPORESOLUCIONpanel" class="multiselectpanel multiselect-container nicescroll dropdown-menu"><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkAUTO" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-sublist="AUTO" value="AUTO" type="checkbox"></label> <a href="#" onclick="showSubTipoRes($('#list_AUTO'), $(this));return false;"><b><b class="fa fa-plus"></b>Car</b></a><ul class="autos hidden" id="list_AUTO"><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkAUTOACLARATORIO" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-chkfather="chkAUTO" data-field="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" 
												value="AUTO ACLARATORIO" type="checkbox" > <b>Self-explanatory</b></label></li><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkAUTORECURSO" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-chkfather="chkAUTO" data-sublist="AUTORECURSO" value="AUTO RECURSO" type="checkbox"></label> <a href="#" onclick="showSubTipoRes($('#list_AUTORECURSO'), $(this));return false;"><b><b class="fa fa-plus"></b>Self appeal (LO 7/2015)</b></a><ul class="autos hidden" id="list_AUTORECURSO"><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkAUTOADMISION" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-chkfather="chkAUTORECURSO" data-field="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" 
														value="AUTO ADMISION" type="checkbox" > <b>Admission car</b></label></li><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkAUTOINADMISION" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-chkfather="chkAUTORECURSO" data-field="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" 
														value="AUTO INADMISION" type="checkbox" > <b>Order of inadmissibility</b></label></li></ul></li><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkAUTOOTROS" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-chkfather="chkAUTO" data-field="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" 
												value="AUTO OTROS" type="checkbox" > <b>Others</b></label></li></ul></li><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkSENTENCIA" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-sublist="SENTENCIA" value="SENTENCIA" type="checkbox"></label> <a href="#" onclick="showSubTipoRes($('#list_SENTENCIA'), $(this));return false;"><b><b class="fa fa-plus"></b>Judgment</b></a><ul class="sentencias hidden" id="list_SENTENCIA"><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkSENTENCIACASACION" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-chkfather="chkSENTENCIA" data-field="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" 
												value="SENTENCIA CASACION" type="checkbox" > <b>Judgment on cassation (LO 7/2015)</b></label></li><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkSENTENCIAOTRAS" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" data-chkfather="chkSENTENCIA" data-field="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" 
												value="SENTENCIA OTRAS" type="checkbox" > <b>Other</b></label></li></ul></li><li class="multiselect-item multiselect-group"> <label class="checkbox"><input id="chkACUERDO" onclick="checkTipoRes($(this));" value="ACUERDO" data-field="SUBTIPORESOLUCION" 
											type="checkbox" > <b>Agreement</b></label> </li></ul></div></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --><!-- sección destino Autos de Admisión del recurso de casación del TSCA --><div class="form-row row" style="display:none;" id="fSeccionAuto"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_SECCIONAUTO" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Destination section</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"><select name="SECCIONAUTO" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_SECCIONAUTO"  class="selectpicker form-control"><option value="" selected> All</option><option value="2" > Second</option><option value="3" > Third</option><option value="4" > Quarter</option><option value="1" > Fifth </option></select></div><!-- .col-sm-4 --></div><!-- .form-row.row #fSeccionAuto--></div><!-- .form-group --><div class="line"></div><!-- bloque 2 end --><!-- bloque 3 start --><div class="form-group row"><!-- obtener órganos, metemos en la page como atributo organos --><div class="form-row row tipoorgano"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOORGANOPUB" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Organ type</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-6 col-md-7 fit"><select id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOORGANOPUB" data-defaultlimit="" name="TIPOORGANOPUB" class="multiselect form-control" multiple="multiple"><option value="11|12|13|14|15|16" > Supreme court</option><option value="11" > Supreme court. Civil Chamber</option><option value="12" > Supreme court. Criminal Chamber</option><option value="13" > Supreme court. Contentious Chamber</option><option value="14" > Supreme court. Social room</option><option value="15" > Supreme court. Military Room</option><option value="16" > Supreme court. Room of the Special</option><option value="22|2264|23|24|26|27|28|29" > National audience</option><option value="22" > National audience. Criminal Chamber</option><option value="2264" > Appeals Chamber of the National Court</option><option value="23" > National audience. Contentious Chamber</option><option value="24" > National audience. Social room</option><option value="27" > National audience. Central Examining Courts</option><option value="26" > National audience. Central Juvenile Court</option><option value="29" > National audience. Central Litigation Courts</option><option value="28" > National audience. Central Criminal Courts</option><option value="31|33|34" > high Court of Justice</option><option value="31" > High Court of Justice. Civil and Criminal Chamber</option><option value="33" > High Court of Justice. Contentious Chamber</option><option value="34" > High Court of Justice. Social room</option><option value="37" > Provincial Court</option><option value="38" > Provincial Court. Jury Court</option><option value="42" > Court of First Instance</option><option value="43" > trial court</option><option value="45" > Administrative Litigation Court</option><option value="53" > Juvenile Court</option><option value="41" > Court of First Instance and Investigation</option><option value="47" > Commercial Court</option><option value="51" > Criminal Court</option><option value="44" > Social Court</option><option value="52" > Penitentiary Surveillance Court</option><option value="48" > Court of Violence against Women</option><option value="83" > Territorial Military Court</option><option value="85" > Central Military Court</option><option value="75" > Supreme Council of Military Justice</option><option value="36" > Territorial Hearing</option></select></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_SECCION" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 col-md-1 control-label">Section</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2"><input type="text" name="SECCION" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_SECCION" class="form-control input-sm" value=""/></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --><div class="form-row row"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_VALUESCOMUNIDAD" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Location</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-10 fit custom"><input type="hidden" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_VALUESCOMUNIDAD" name="VALUESCOMUNIDAD" value=""/><div class="btn-group "> <button data-toggle="dropdown" id="COMUNIDADmultiselec" data-selected="" 
								 	
								 	data-placement="bottom" class="multiselect dropdown-toggle btn btn-default tooltips clearable" type="button" title="All"><span class="multiselect-selected-text">All</span><b class="caret"></b></button> <ul id="COMUNIDADpanel" class="multiselectpanel multiselect-container nicescroll dropdown-menu"></ul></div></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --></div><!-- .form-group --><div class="line"></div><!-- bloque 3 end --><!-- bloque 4 start --><div class="form-group row"><div class="form-row row"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ROJ" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">ROJ No.</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"><input type="text" name="ROJ" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ROJ" class="form-control input-sm" value=""/></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ECLI" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">ECLI</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"><input type="text" name="ECLI" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ECLI" class="form-control input-sm cleardates" placeholder="ECLI:ES:TS:2014:3877" value=""/></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --><div class="form-row row"><div class="fieldyears"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_FECHARESOLUCIONDESDE" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Resolution date</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 fielddates"><div class='col-xs-12 input-group date datetimepicker' id='frmBusquedajurisprudencia_FECHADESDE'><input type='text' class="form-control" id='frmBusquedajurisprudencia_FECHARESOLUCIONDESDE' name="FECHARESOLUCIONDESDE" 
									placeholder="Desde" value=""/><span class="input-group-addon"><span class="fa fa-calendar"></span></span> </div><!-- .datetimepicker --></div><!-- .col-sm-4 --></div><!-- .fieldyears --><!-- años seleccionados --><div id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_SHOW_ANYOS" style="display: none;" class="showyears"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_ANYOS" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Years</label><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 tooltips"><div class="form-control input-sm years"></div></div></div><!-- .form-row.row.showyears --> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_NUMERORESOLUCION" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Resolution No.</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"><input type="text" name="NUMERORESOLUCION" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_NUMERORESOLUCION" class="form-control input-sm" value=""/></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --><div class="form-row row"><div class="fieldyears"><label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_FECHARESOLUCIONHASTA" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label"> </label><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 fielddates"><div class='col-xs-12 input-group date datetimepicker' id='frmBusquedajurisprudencia_FECHAHASTA'><input type='text' class="form-control" id='frmBusquedajurisprudencia_FECHARESOLUCIONHASTA' name="FECHARESOLUCIONHASTA" 
									placeholder="Hasta" value=""/><span class="input-group-addon"><span class="fa fa-calendar"></span></span> </div><!-- .datetimepicker2 --></div></div><!-- .fieldyears --><label class="col-sm-2 showyears control-label" style="display:none;"></label><div class="col-sm-4 showyears" style="display:none;"></div> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_NUMERORECURSO" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Resource No.</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"><input type="text" name="NUMERORECURSO" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_NUMERORECURSO" class="form-control input-sm" value=""/></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --></div><!-- .form-group --><div class="line"></div><!-- bloque 4 end --><!-- bloque 5 start --><div class="form-group row"><div class="form-row row"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_PONENTE" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Speaker</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-10"><input type="text" name="PONENTE" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_PONENTE" class="form-control input-sm autocomplete addoperators showtooltip" value=""/></div><!-- .col-sm-9 --></div><!-- .form-row --><div class="form-row row"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_IDIOMA" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Language</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"><select id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_IDIOMA" name="IDIOMA" class="selectpicker form-control"><option value="" selected> All</option><option value="1" > Spanish</option><option value="2" > Català</option><option value="3" > Galego</option><option value="4" > Basque </option><!-- se carga por ajax --></select></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --></div><!-- .form-group --><!-- bloque 5 end --><!-- bloque 6 start --><!-- se puede deshabilitar en indexAN.jsp --><div id="linea_NORMA" class="line hidden-xs"></div><div id="bloque_NORMA" class="form-group row hidden-xs"><div class="form-row row"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_NORMA" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Legislation</label><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-10"><div class="fielddesc"> Only sentences that cite the selected standard will be searched. </div><div class="col-xs-12 nopad"><div class="col-xs-11 nopad"><input type="text" name="NORMA" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_NORMA" readonly class="pull-left form-control clearable input-sm autocomplete showtooltip" 
											data-parse="false" data-clear-cb="clearNorma" title="Search for the provisions cited in the resolutions of the Documentary Fund" value=""/></div><!-- .col-xs-11 --><div class="col-xs-1"> <a href="#" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_lnchnorma" class="tooltips" title="Open rule finder"><img src="/search/img/normas.png" /></a> </div><!-- .col-xs-1 --></div></div><!-- .col-sm-8 --></div><!-- .form-row --></div><!-- .form-group --><div class="line"></div><!-- bloque 6 end --><!-- bloque 7 start --><div class="form-group row"><div class="form-row row"> <label class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Search only</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-5"><ul class="historico"><li class="tooltips" data-placement="bottom" title="Search up to and including 1978"> <label class="check-label" for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_HISTORICOPUBLICO"><input type="checkbox" name="HISTORICOPUBLICO" value="true" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_HISTORICOPUBLICO" /> History of the Supreme Court</label></li><li> <label class="check-label" for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_INTERES"><input type="checkbox" name="TIPOINTERES_INTERES" value="Interés" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_INTERES" /> Resolutions of matching interest</label></li><li> <label class="check-label" for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_ACTUAL"><input type="checkbox" name="TIPOINTERES_ACTUAL" value="Actualidad" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_ACTUAL" /> Current resolutions</label></li></ul></div><!-- .col-sm-5 --><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-5"><ul class="historico"><li><label class="check-label" for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_JURIDICO"><input type="checkbox" name="TIPOINTERES_JURIDICO" value="Interés Jurídico" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_JURIDICO" /> Resolutions of legal interest (TS studies)</label></li><li> <label class="check-label" for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_LECTURAFACIL"><input type="checkbox" name="TIPOINTERES_LECTURAFACIL" value="Lectura fácil" id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_TIPOINTERES_LECTURAFACIL" /> Easy-to-read resolutions</label> </li></ul></div><!-- .col-sm-9 --></div><!-- .form-row --></div><!-- .form-group --><div class="line"></div><!-- bloque 7 end --><!-- bloque 8 start --><div class="form-group row"><div class="form-row row"> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_recordsPerPage" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Results</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 results"><select id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_recordsPerPage" name="recordsPerPage" class="selectpicker form-control"><option value="10"> 10</option><option value="20"> twenty</option><option value="30"> 30</option><option value="50"> fifty</option></select></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --> <label for="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_sort" class="col-xs-12 col-sm-2 control-label">Sort by</label> <div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"><select id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_sort" name="sort" class="selectpicker form-control"><option value="Relevance"> Coincidence</option><option value="IN_FECHARESOLUCION:increasing"> Date Resol. [0..9]</option><option value="IN_FECHARESOLUCION:decreasing" selected="true"> Date Resol. [9..0]</option><option value="IN_FECHAENTRADA:numberdecreasing"> The most new</option><option value="IP_TIPOORGANO:alphabetical"> Organ [a..z]</option><option value="IP_TIPOORGANO:reversealphabetical"> Organ [z..a] </option></select></div><!-- .col-xs-12 --></div><!-- .form-row --></div><!-- .form-group --><div class="line"></div><!-- bloque 8 end --><!-- botonera --><div class="botonera row"><div id="frmBusquedajurisprudencia_botonera" class="form-row row pull-right"> <button id="srcjur_clean" type="button" class="btn btn-default btn-sm">Clear</button> <button id="srcjur_search" type="submit" class="btn btn-primary btn-sm">Search</button> </div><!-- #frmBusquedajurisprudencia_botonera --></div><!-- .botonera --><!-- botonera end --></form></div><!-- #jurformsearch --><!-- hide sidebar --><div class="togglerightsidebar hidden-xs"> <a href="#" class="tooltips" data-toggle="tooltip" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Mostrar/Ocultar la barra lateral"><img src="/search/img/right_sbhide.png"></a> </div><!-- .togglesidebar --><!-- hide sidebar end --></div><!-- #mainjurisprudenciasearch --><!-- right sidebar start--><aside><div class="rightsidebar"><div class="row"><div class="actualdocs col-xs-12"><h2> <span class="tooltips" title="The most seen" data-container="body"><img style="width:18px;height:19px;" src="/search/img/masvisto.png" alt="Most consulted resolutions"/></span> Most consulted resolutions</h2><div class="docslist"><div class="actual doc col-sm-6 col-md-4"> <a class="tooltips docinfo" title="STS 10575/2018. "Gürtel"." data-container="body" 
	                                        href="https://www.poderjudicial.es/search/AN/openDocument/5ca6d6aa519d1971/20201027"
	                                        onclick="markOpenedDoc($(this));openDocumentFromHref(this);return false;"
	                                        data-databasematch="TS" data-reference="9290600" data-optimize="20201027" data-roj="STS 3191/2020"
	                                        data-calledfrom="docsactualidad">STS 3191/2020</a> <span class="fecha">Gürtel.</span></div><!-- ..actual.doc --><div class="actual doc col-sm-6 col-md-4"> <a class="tooltips docinfo" title="STS Plenary: Right of dispensation." data-container="body" 
	                                        href="https://www.poderjudicial.es/search/AN/openDocument/3d97ed62a01847f6/20200804"
	                                        onclick="markOpenedDoc($(this));openDocumentFromHref(this);return false;"
	                                        data-databasematch="TS" data-reference="9209917" data-optimize="20200804" data-roj="STS 2493/2020"
	                                        data-calledfrom="docsactualidad">STS 2493/2020</a> <span class="fecha">Right of dispensation.</span></div><!-- ..actual.doc --><div class="actual doc col-sm-6 col-md-4"> <a class="tooltips docinfo" title="PV hospitality reopening." data-container="body" 
	                                        href="https://www.poderjudicial.es/search/AN/openDocument/1286da023d243b04/20210210"
	                                        onclick="markOpenedDoc($(this));openDocumentFromHref(this);return false;"
	                                        data-databasematch="AN" data-reference="9408125" data-optimize="20210210" data-roj="ATSJ PV 2/2021"
	                                        data-calledfrom="docsactualidad">ATSJ PV 2/2021</a> <span class="fecha">Reopening of the PV hospitality industry.</span> </div><!-- ..actual.doc --></div><!-- .docslist --></div><!-- .actualdocs --></div><!-- .row --><div class="row"><div id="tagcloud" class="col-xs-12"><h2><span><img src="/search/img/temas.png" alt="Sentences by topic"/></span> Sentences by topic</h2><div class="tagcloud-data"><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="marron"><a href="/search/tema/Real Decreto alarma sanitaria Covid-19/1/AN">Royal Decree health alarm Covid-19</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="rojo"><a href="/search/sentencias/condiciones generales de la contratacion/1/AN">general contracting conditions</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="verde"><a href="/search/sentencias/hipoteca/1/AN">mortgage</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="naranja"><a href="/search/sentencias/derecho financiero y tributario/1/AN">financial and tax law</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="rojo"><a href="/search/sentencias/recurso de casacion (lo 7/2015)/1/AN">appeal (the 7/2015)</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="naranja"><a href="/search/sentencias/jurisdiccion y competencia (proceso laboral)/1/AN">jurisdiction and competence (labor process)</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="verde"><a href="/search/sentencias/limites de la jurisdiccion laboral/1/AN">limits of labor jurisdiction</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="naranja"><a href="/search/sentencias/derecho a la tutela judicial efectiva/1/AN">Right to effective judicial protection</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="rojo"><a href="/search/sentencias/delitos contra las personas/1/AN">crimes against people</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="verde"><a href="/search/sentencias/derecho a la defensa/1/AN">right to defense</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="verde"><a href="/search/sentencias/garantias sociales/1/AN">social guarantees</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="naranja"><a href="/search/sentencias/duracion (contrato de trabajo)/1/AN">duration (employment contract)</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="rojo"><a href="/search/sentencias/condiciones generales de la contratacion/1/AN">general contracting conditions</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="naranja"><a href="/search/sentencias/proteccion del consumidor y usuario/1/AN">consumer and user protection</a></span><!-- en el caso de ser tipo tema, la url es tema --> <span class="verde"><a href="/search/sentencias/derecho disciplinario militar/1/AN">military disciplinary law</a></span> </div></div><!-- #tagcloud --></div><!-- .row --><div class="row hidden-xs"><div id="last50results" class="col-xs-12"><h2><span><img src="/search/img/last50.png" alt="Latest rulings of the Supreme Court"/></span> Latest rulings of the Supreme Court </h2><div class="last50results-data"><ul class="nav nav-tabs hidden-xs hidden-sm"><li data-tab="CIVIL" class="tab-lastTS"> <a href="#">CIVIL</a></li><li data-tab="PENAL" class="tab-lastTS"> <a href="#">PENAL</a></li><li data-tab="contencioso" class="tab-lastTS"> <a href="#">CONTENTIOUS</a></li><li data-tab="SOCIAL" class="tab-lastTS"> <a href="#">SOCIAL</a></li><li data-tab="MILITAR" class="tab-lastTS"> <a href="#">MILITARY</a></li><li data-tab="ESPECIAL" class="tab-lastTS"> <a href="#">SPECIAL</a> </li></ul><!-- Tab panes --><div class="lststabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-CIVIL"></div><div class="lststabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-PENAL"></div><div class="lststabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-contencioso"><div id="secciones"><ul class="nav nav-tabs hidden-xs hidden-sm"><li data-tab="Sec-1" data-jurisdiccion="CONTENCIOSO" class="tab-seccion"> <a href="#">Sec. 1</a></li><li data-tab="Sec-2" data-jurisdiccion="CONTENCIOSO" class="tab-seccion"> <a href="#">Sec. 2</a></li><li data-tab="Sec-3" data-jurisdiccion="CONTENCIOSO" class="tab-seccion"> <a href="#">Sec. 3</a></li><li data-tab="Sec-4" data-jurisdiccion="CONTENCIOSO" class="tab-seccion"> <a href="#">Sec. 4</a></li><li data-tab="Sec-5" data-jurisdiccion="CONTENCIOSO" class="tab-seccion"> <a href="#">Sec. 5</a> </li></ul><div class="secciontabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-Sec-1"></div><div class="secciontabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-Sec-2"></div><div class="secciontabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-Sec-3"></div><div class="secciontabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-Sec-4"></div><div class="secciontabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-Sec-5"></div></div></div><div class="lststabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-SOCIAL"></div><div class="lststabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-MILITAR"></div><div class="lststabcontent" id="lastsentenceTS-ESPECIAL"></div></div><!-- .last50results-data --></div><!-- #last50results --></div><!-- se puede deshabilitar en indexAN.jsp --><div id="legpanel" class="col-xs-12  hidden-xs" style="display:none;"><div id="normas"><div id="layoutnorma" class="advanced"><h2> Use the provision finder to find standards<br/> that are cited in the different resolutions of the documentary collection. <a href="#" class="dissmis tooltips" data-placement="top" data-container="#jurisprudenciasearch" title="To close"><i class="fa fa-times"></i></a> </h2><div id="busquedaNormas" class="searchform row"><form id="searchNormaForm" action="#"><input type="hidden" id="searchNormaForm_action" name="action" value="getNormasList"/><input type="hidden" id="searchNormaForm_start" name="start" value="1"/><input type="hidden" id="searchNormaForm_recordsPerPage" name="recordsPerPage" value="20"/><input type="hidden" id="searchNormaForm_maxresults" name="maxresults" value="0"/><input type="hidden" id="searchNormaForm_page" name="page" value="1"/><input type="hidden" id="searchNormaForm_databasematch" name="databasematch" value="legislacion"/><div class="row"><div class="col-xs-11"><div class="input-group m-bot15"><input type="text" name="TITULO" id="searchNormaForm_TEXTNorma" onkeyup="searchNorma();" autocomplete="off" class="form-control input-sm" /><span class="input-group-btn"><button href="#" class="btn btn-default"><i class="fa fa-search"> </i></button></span><!-- .input-group-btn --></div><!-- .input-group --></div><!-- .col-xs-11 --><div class="col-xs-1 nopad"> <a href="#" id="searchNormaForm_advanced" class="tooltips pull-left" data-placement="bottom" title="Advanced / simple search"><i class="fa fa-minus"></i></a></div><!-- .col-xs-1 --></div><!-- .row --><div id="advancedSearchNorm" class="advancedform active"><div class="form-group row"><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 nopad"> <label for="searchNormaForm_NOFICIAL" class="control-label">Official number</label> <input type="text" name="NOFICIAL" id="searchNormaForm_NOFICIAL" class="form-control input-sm" /></div><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"> <label for="searchNormaForm_NBOE" class="control-label">BOE No.</label> <input type="text" name="NBOE" id="searchNormaForm_NBOE" class="form-control input-sm" /></div><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"> <label for="searchNormaForm_NREFERENCIA" class="control-label">No. Refer.</label> <input type="text" name="NREFERENCIA" id="searchNormaForm_NREFERENCIA" class="form-control input-sm"></div></div><div class="form-group row"><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4 nopad"> <label for="searchNormaForm_RANGO" class="control-label">Rank</label> <input type="text" name="RANGO" id="searchNormaForm_RANGO" class="form-control input-sm" /></div><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"> <label for="searchNormaForm_DEPARTAMENTO" class="control-label">Organ</label> <input type="text" name="DEPARTAMENTO" id="searchNormaForm_DEPARTAMENTO" class="form-control input-sm" /></div><div class="col-xs-12 col-sm-4"> <label for="searchNormaForm_MATERIAS" class="control-label">Subject</label> <input type="text" name="MATERIAS" id="searchNormaForm_MATERIAS" class="form-control input-sm" /></div></div><div class="form-group row fielddates"> <label for="searchNormaForm_FECHAPUBLICACIONDESDE" class="col-xs-2 control-label nopad">Fª Public.</label> <div class="col-xs-9"><div class="col-xs-6 nopad tooltips" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Desde"><div class='input-group date datetimepicker'><input type='text' id='searchNormaForm_FECHAPUBLICACIONDESDE' class="form-control" name="FECHAPUBLICACIONDESDE"/><span class="input-group-addon"><span class="fa fa-calendar"></span></span> </div><!-- .input-group --></div><!-- .col-xs-6 --><div class="col-xs-6 nopad tooltips" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Hasta"><div class='input-group date datetimepicker'><input type='text' id='searchNormaForm_FECHAPUBLICACIONHASTA' class="form-control" name="FECHAPUBLICACIONHASTA"/><span class="input-group-addon"><span class="fa fa-calendar"></span></span> </div><!-- .input-group --></div><!-- .col-xs-6 --></div><!-- .col-xs-9 --></div><!-- .form-group --><div class="form-group row fielddates"> <label for="searchNormaForm_FECHAAPLICACIONDESDE" class="col-xs-2 control-label nopad">Fª Dispos.</label> <div class="col-xs-9"><div class="col-xs-6 nopad tooltips" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Desde"><div class='input-group date datetimepicker'><input type='text' id='searchNormaForm_FECHAAPLICACIONDESDE' class="form-control" name="FECHAAPLICACIONDESDE"/><span class="input-group-addon"><span class="fa fa-calendar"></span></span> </div><!-- .input-group --></div><!-- .col-xs-6 --><div class="col-xs-6 nopad tooltips" data-placement="bottom" data-original-title="Hasta"><div class='input-group date datetimepicker'><input type='text' id='searchNormaForm_FECHAAPLICACIONHASTA' class="form-control" name="FECHAAPLICACIONHASTA"/><span class="input-group-addon"><span class="fa fa-calendar"></span></span> </div><!-- .input-group --></div><!-- .col-xs-6 --></div><!-- .col-xs-9 --></div><!-- .form-group --></div><!-- #advancedSearchNorm --></form></div><!-- .row  --><div id="layoutNormaResults" class="hidden row"></div><!-- #layoutNormaResults  --><div id="normasquery" style="display: none;"><ul></ul></div></div><!-- #layoutnorma --></div><!-- #normas --></div><!-- #legpanel --></div><!-- .rightsidebar --></aside><!-- right sidebar end--></div><!-- #jurisprudenciasearch --><div id="jurisprudenciaresults" class="results bbsubtabcontent "></div><!-- #jurisprudenciaresults --><div id="jurisprudenciacontent" class="content bbsubtabcontent clearfix"><div class="docactions" style="display:none;"><ul><li class="social tooltips" title="Share on Facebook" data-placement="bottom"><a href="#" class="fb-button"><i class="fa fa-facebook-square"></i></a></li><li class="social tooltips" title="share on Twitter" data-placement="bottom"><a href="#" class="twtr-button"><i class="fa fa-twitter-square"></i></a></li><li class="social tooltips" title="copy link" data-placement="bottom"><a href="#" class="cp-button"><i class="fa fa-clipboard"></i></a></li><li class="social tooltips" title="Open the document in a new window" data-placement="bottom"><a href="#" class="new-button"><i class="fa fa-external-link"></i></a> </li><li class="hidden lecturafacil tooltips" title="Download resolution in easy reading" data-placement="bottom"><a href="#" class="lecturafacil-button"><img alt="easy reading" src="/search/img/lecturafacil.png"/></a> </li></ul></div><div class="embed-responsive embed-responsive-16by9"><object id="objtcontentpdf" data="/search/contenidos.action?action=accessToPDF&publicinterface=true&tab=AN&reference=52c2d7a2a876c5d9&encode=true&optimize=20210325&databasematch=AN" type="application/pdf" width="90%" height="100%"><p> It seems you don't have the plugin configured to view the embedded pdf ... you can download the resolution <a href="/search/contenidos.action?action=accessToPDF&publicinterface=true&tab=AN&reference=52c2d7a2a876c5d9&encode=true&optimize=20210325&databasematch=AN" target="_blank">here</a> . </p></object></div></div><!-- #jurisprudenciacontent --></section><!-- #jurisprudencia --><!--tab jurisprudencia end --></section><!--main content end--></div><!-- .row --></div><!-- .container-fluid --><footer><div class="container-fluid"><!-- .container-fluid --><div class="footer"> Copyright © General Council of the Judiciary </div></div><!-- .container-fluid --></footer></section><!-- #main-container --><!-- Modal aviso legal--><div id="modalAvisoLegal" class="modal fade" role="dialog"><div class="modal-dialog"><!-- Modal content--><div class="modal-content"><div class="modal-header"><button type="button" class="close" data-dismiss="modal">×</button><h4 class="modal-title"> Legal warning</h4></div><!-- .modal-header --><div class="modal-body"><p> The resolutions that make up this database are disseminated for the purposes of knowledge and consultation of the decision criteria of the Courts, in compliance with the competence granted to the General Council of the Judiciary by art. 560.1.10º of the Organic Law of the Judicial Power.</p><p> The database user will be able to consult the documents as long as he does so for his own personal use.</p><p> The use of the database for commercial uses, nor the massive download of information is not allowed. The reuse of this information for the preparation of databases or for commercial purposes must follow the procedure and conditions established by the CGPJ through its Judicial Documentation Center.</p> Any action that contravenes the above indications may lead to the adoption of the appropriate legal measures. </div><!-- .modal-body --></div><!-- .modal-content --></div><!-- .modal-dialog-content --></div><!-- #modalAvisoLegal --><!-- Modal para errores --><div id="errorsModal" class="modal error" role="dialog"><div class="modal-dialog"><!-- Modal content--><div class="modal-content"><div class="modal-header"><button type="button" class="close" data-dismiss="modal">×</button></div><div class="modal-body"><h2> Sorry, something went wrong!<p> <b>Please, try again.</b> </p></h2><div class="message"></div></div></div><!-- .modal-content --></div><!-- .modal-dialog-content --></div><!-- #errorsModal --><!-- Modal ayudas --><div id="modalAyudas" class="modal fade" role="dialog"><div class="modal-dialog"><!-- Modal content--><div class="modal-content"><div class="modal-header"><button type="button" class="close" data-dismiss="modal">×</button><h4 class="modal-title"> HELP / INFORMATION </h4></div><!-- .modal-header --><div class="modal-body"></div><!-- .modal-body --><div class="modal-footer"></div><!-- .modal-footer --></div><!-- .modal-content --></div><!-- .modal-dialog-content --></div><!-- #modalAyudas --><!-- Modal para warnings --><div id="warnModal" class="modal warn" role="dialog"><div class="modal-dialog"><!-- Modal content--><div class="modal-content"><div class="modal-header"><button type="button" class="close" data-dismiss="modal">×</button> </div><div class="modal-body"><div class="message"></div></div></div><!-- .modal-content --></div><!-- .modal-dialog-content --></div><!-- #warnModal --><link rel="localizations" href="/search/js/locales.json?guid=202103311549" type="application/vnd.oftn.l10n+json"/><script type="text/javascript" src="/search/js/common-scripts/ext/l10n.js"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/start-scripts.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/start-scripts.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="/search/js/common-scripts/stats.js?guid=202103311549" type="text/javascript"></script><script type="text/javascript">

			var STATS_SERVICE_URL;
		
			STATS_SERVICE_URL = "//jurisestad.poderjudicial.es/stats/service.action";
		
			var statsSession = {
				session: '9824A5C427CA61016438376794176E97.sidolapp04',
				ip: '159.69.137.93',
			
			
				geo_pais: 'DE',
				geo_ccaa: '',
				geo_prov: '',
				browser: 'UNKNOWN',
				version: '',
				mobile: 'false'
			};
	
			var statsData = {
				portal: 'publico',
				tab: 'indexAN',
				statsSession: statsSession
			};
		
		</script></body></html>
Retrieved from "https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?title=AN_-_578/2021&oldid=14661"
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike
Powered by MediaWiki