Editing Rb. Amsterdam - C/13/694440 / KG ZA 20-1118

From GDPRhub

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 100: Line 100:
  
 
<pre>
 
<pre>
Statement
+
<!doctype html><html lang="nl"><head id="Head1" runat="server" profile="http://www.w3.org/2005/10/profile"><meta name="referrer" content="origin-when-cross-origin" /><title> ECLI: NL: RBAMS: 2021: 174, Amsterdam District Court, C / 13/694440 / KG ZA 20-1118 </title><meta charset="utf-8"><meta http-equiv="x-ua-compatible" content="ie=edge"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"><link rel="shortcut icon" type="image/ico" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/favicon.ico" /><link rel="icon" type="image/ico" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/favicon.ico" /><!-- apple touch iconen--><link rel="apple-touch-icon" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="57x57" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-57x57.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="72x72" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-72x72.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="76x76" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-76x76.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="114x114" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-114x114.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="120x120" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-120x120.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="144x144" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-144x144.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="152x152" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-152x152.png" /><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/apple-touch-iconen/apple-touch-icon-180x180.png" /><!-- android icoon --><link rel="icon" sizes="192x192" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/android-icon-192x192.png"><!-- Bootstrap --><link type="text/css" rel="Stylesheet" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?css/bootstrap/bootstrap-3.3.6.custom.min.css" /><!-- Rechtspraak --><link type="text/css" rel="Stylesheet" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?css/rechtspraak/rechtspraak.sjablonen.custom.min.css" /><script src="/SharedWebResources.axd?js/jquery/jquery-1.11.0.min.js"></script><!-- bs dropdown via javascript --><script>
 +
    $(function () {
 +
        $('.dropdown.rs-mega-menu > a')
 +
            .attr('data-toggle', 'dropdown');
 +
    });
 +
</script><script src="/SharedWebResources.axd?js/bootstrap/bootstrap-3.3.6.min.js"></script><!-- Uitspraken --><link type="text/css" rel="Stylesheet" href="/Content/css/slimbox/slimbox2.css" media="screen" /><link type="text/css" rel="Stylesheet" href="/Content/css/rechtspraak.uitspraken.min.css" /><link type="text/css" rel="Stylesheet" href="/Content/css/print-uitspraak.min.css" media="print" /><link type="text/css" rel="Stylesheet" href="/SharedWebResources.axd?css/calendar.css" /><link id="highlightsh" type="text/css" rel="Stylesheet" disabled href="/Content/css/disable.uitspraak.highlight.min.css" /><script type="text/javascript">
 +
                (function (window, document, dataLayerName, id) {
 +
                function stgCreateCookie(a, b, c) { var d = ""; if (c) { var e = new Date; e.setTime(e.getTime() + 24 * c * 60 * 60 * 1e3), d = "; expires=" + e.toUTCString() } document.cookie = a + "=" + b + d + "; path=/" }
 +
                var isStgDebug = (window.location.href.match("stg_debug") || document.cookie.match("stg_debug")) && !window.location.href.match("stg_disable_debug"); stgCreateCookie("stg_debug", isStgDebug ? 1 : "", isStgDebug ? 14 : -1);
 +
                var qP = []; dataLayerName !== "dataLayer" && qP.push("data_layer_name=" + dataLayerName), isStgDebug && qP.push("stg_debug"); var qPString = qP.length > 0 ? ("?" + qP.join("&")) : "";
 +
                document.write('<script src="https://statistiek.rechtspraak.nl/containers/' + id + '.sync.js' + qPString + '"></' + 'script>');
 +
                })(window, document, 'dataLayer', '11b7c5ed-2b4c-406d-9d93-8e2bcf98a2dd');
 +
            </script><meta property="dcterms:identifier" content="ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174" datatype="xsd:anyURI" /><meta property="dcterms:title" content="ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174, Rechtbank Amsterdam, C/13/694440 / KG ZA 20-1118" /><meta property="dcterms:issued" content="2021-01-29" datatype="xsd:date" /><link rel="dcterms:publisher" /><link rel="dcterms:type" href="http://psi.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak" title="Statement" /><meta property="dcterms:language" content="nl" datatype="xsd:language" /><meta property="dcterms:creator" content="&lt;span&gt;Rechtbank Amsterdam&lt;/span&gt;" scheme="overheid.RechterlijkeMacht" resourceidentifier="http://standaarden.overheid.nl/owms/terms/Rechtbank_Amsterdam" /><meta property="dcterms:modified" content="2021-01-29" datatype="xsd:date" /><meta property="dcterms:abstract" content="&lt;inhoudsindicatie xmlns=&quot;http://www.rechtspraak.nl/schema/rechtspraak-1.0&quot; id=&quot;ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174:INH&quot; lang=&quot;nl&quot; xml:space=&quot;preserve&quot;&gt;&lt;para&gt;kort geding, tussenvonnis, prejudici&#235;le vragen, grondslag BKR-registratie&lt;/para&gt;&lt;/inhoudsindicatie&gt;" /><meta property="dcterms:created" content="2021-01-21" datatype="xsd:date" /><link rel="dcterms:subject" href="http://psi.rechtspraak.nl/rechtsgebied#civielRecht" title="Civil rights" /><link rel="canonical" href="https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/inziendocument?id=ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174" /></head><body><div class="rs-wrapper"><div class="rs-header"><div class="container"><div class="rs-logo"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl" title="Homepage Rechtspraak.nl"><img class="ms-siteicon-img" src="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/logo_2016.png" alt="Logo of the judiciary" /></a> <!--  <img src="data:image/svg+xml, %3Csvg version%3D%221.1%22 id%3D%22logo%22 xmlns%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.w3.org%2F2000%2Fsvg%22 xmlns%3Axlink%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fwww.w3.org%2F1999%2Fxlink%22 x%3D%220px%22 y%3D%220px%22    viewBox%3D%220 0 117 71%22 style%3D%22enable-background%3Anew 0 0 117 71%3B%22 xml%3Aspace%3D%22preserve%22%3E%3Cstyle type%3D%22text%2Fcss%22%3E    .st0%7Bfill%3Anone%3B%7D    .st1%7Bfill%3A%23151F6D%3B%7D    .st2%7Bfill%3A%23AA0061%3B%7D%3C%2Fstyle%3E%3Cg%3E    %3Cg%3E        %3Cg%3E            %3Cg%3E                %3Cg%3E                    %3Cg%3E                        %3Cg%3E                            %3Crect x%3D%22-19.4%22 y%3D%22-5.2%22 class%3D%22st0%22 width%3D%22155.9%22 height%3D%2287.9%22%2F%3E                        %3C%2Fg%3E                    %3C%2Fg%3E                %3C%2Fg%3E            %3C%2Fg%3E        %3C%2Fg%3E    %3C%2Fg%3E    %3Cg%3E        %3Cg%3E            %3Cg%3E                %3Cg%3E                %3C%2Fg%3E            %3C%2Fg%3E        %3C%2Fg%3E    %3C%2Fg%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M11.7%2C65.6c0.1%2C1%2C0.9%2C1.7%2C1.9%2C1.7c0.9%2C0%2C1.5-0.4%2C1.9-1l1.3%2C1c-0.8%2C1-1.9%2C1.4-3%2C1.4c-2.1%2C0-3.8-1.5-3.8-3.7        c0-2.2%2C1.6-3.7%2C3.7-3.7c2%2C0%2C3.4%2C1.4%2C3.4%2C3.8v0.5H11.7z M15.3%2C64.3c0-1-0.7-1.7-1.8-1.7c-1%2C0-1.7%2C0.7-1.8%2C1.7H15.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M35.7%2C65.6c0.1%2C1%2C0.9%2C1.7%2C1.9%2C1.7c0.9%2C0%2C1.5-0.4%2C1.9-1l1.3%2C1c-0.8%2C1-1.9%2C1.4-3%2C1.4c-2.1%2C0-3.8-1.5-3.8-3.7        c0-2.2%2C1.6-3.7%2C3.7-3.7c2%2C0%2C3.4%2C1.4%2C3.4%2C3.8v0.5H35.7z M39.3%2C64.3c0-1-0.7-1.7-1.8-1.7c-1%2C0-1.7%2C0.7-1.8%2C1.7H39.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M48.4%2C63.5c-0.4-0.4-0.9-0.7-1.4-0.7c-1.3%2C0-2.1%2C1.1-2.1%2C2.2c0%2C1.1%2C0.8%2C2.2%2C2.1%2C2.2c0.5%2C0%2C1.1-0.2%2C1.4-0.7        l1.2%2C1.2c-0.7%2C0.7-1.9%2C1-2.5%2C1c-2.1%2C0-3.8-1.5-3.8-3.7c0-2.2%2C1.7-3.7%2C3.8-3.7c0.9%2C0%2C1.9%2C0.3%2C2.5%2C1.1L48.4%2C63.5z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M71.8%2C63.4c-0.3-0.5-0.8-0.7-1.4-0.7c-0.5%2C0-1%2C0.3-1%2C0.8c0%2C1.3%2C3.8%2C0.2%2C3.8%2C3c0%2C1.7-1.5%2C2.3-3%2C2.3        c-1.1%2C0-2.1-0.3-2.8-1.1l1.1-1.1c0.5%2C0.5%2C1%2C0.8%2C1.7%2C0.8c0.5%2C0%2C1.2-0.3%2C1.2-0.8c0-1.5-3.8-0.3-3.8-3c0-1.6%2C1.4-2.3%2C2.9-2.3        c0.9%2C0%2C1.9%2C0.3%2C2.5%2C1.1L71.8%2C63.4z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M96.7%2C67.5L96.7%2C67.5c-0.5%2C0.8-1.4%2C1.1-2.3%2C1.1c-1.3%2C0-2.6-0.7-2.6-2.1c0-2.3%2C2.7-2.4%2C4.4-2.4h0.4v-0.2        c0-0.9-0.7-1.3-1.6-1.3c-0.7%2C0-1.4%2C0.3-1.9%2C0.7l-0.9-0.9c0.8-0.8%2C1.8-1.1%2C3-1.1c3%2C0%2C3%2C2.2%2C3%2C3.2v4h-1.6V67.5z M96.6%2C65.3h-0.4        c-1%2C0-2.6%2C0.1-2.6%2C1.1c0%2C0.6%2C0.7%2C0.9%2C1.2%2C0.9c1.1%2C0%2C1.8-0.6%2C1.8-1.6V65.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M105.7%2C67.5L105.7%2C67.5c-0.5%2C0.8-1.4%2C1.1-2.3%2C1.1c-1.3%2C0-2.6-0.7-2.6-2.1c0-2.3%2C2.7-2.4%2C4.4-2.4h0.4v-0.2        c0-0.9-0.7-1.3-1.6-1.3c-0.7%2C0-1.4%2C0.3-1.9%2C0.7l-0.9-0.9c0.8-0.8%2C1.8-1.1%2C3-1.1c3%2C0%2C3%2C2.2%2C3%2C3.2v4h-1.6V67.5z M105.7%2C65.3h-0.4        c-1%2C0-2.6%2C0.1-2.6%2C1.1c0%2C0.6%2C0.7%2C0.9%2C1.2%2C0.9c1.1%2C0%2C1.8-0.6%2C1.8-1.6V65.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M5.7%2C58.7v3.7h0c-0.4-0.5-1.1-1.1-2.4-1.1c-2%2C0-3.4%2C1.6-3.4%2C3.7c0%2C2.1%2C1.3%2C3.7%2C3.5%2C3.7c1%2C0%2C1.9-0.4%2C2.4-1.2h0        v1.1h1.7v-9.8H5.7z M3.7%2C67.1c-1.3%2C0-2.1-1.1-2.1-2.2c0-1.1%2C0.8-2.2%2C2.1-2.2s2.1%2C1.1%2C2.1%2C2.2C5.8%2C66.1%2C5%2C67.1%2C3.7%2C67.1z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M55.6%2C61.3c-1.1%2C0-1.8%2C0.6-2.1%2C1.2h0v-3.7h-1.8v9.8h1.8v-3.8c0-0.9%2C0.5-1.8%2C1.6-1.8c1.2%2C0%2C1.3%2C1.3%2C1.3%2C2.1v3.6        h1.8v-4.4C58.2%2C62.6%2C57.5%2C61.3%2C55.6%2C61.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpolygon class%3D%22st1%22 points%3D%22113.9%2C64.7 116.9%2C61.5 114.6%2C61.5 111.9%2C64.4 111.9%2C58.7 110.2%2C58.7 110.2%2C68.5 111.9%2C68.5        111.9%2C64.9 112%2C64.9 114.8%2C68.5 117.1%2C68.5  %22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M79.9%2C61.3c-1%2C0-1.9%2C0.4-2.4%2C1.2h0v-1.1h-1.7V71h1.8v-3.4h0c0.4%2C0.5%2C1.1%2C1.1%2C2.4%2C1.1c2%2C0%2C3.4-1.6%2C3.4-3.7        C83.4%2C62.9%2C82.1%2C61.3%2C79.9%2C61.3z M79.6%2C67.1c-1.3%2C0-2.1-1.1-2.1-2.2c0-1.1%2C0.8-2.2%2C2.1-2.2c1.3%2C0%2C2.1%2C1.1%2C2.1%2C2.2        C81.6%2C66.1%2C80.8%2C67.1%2C79.6%2C67.1z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M26.4%2C68.5v-3.9h1.3l2.4%2C3.9h2.1l-2.6-4.1c1.5-0.2%2C2.4-1.3%2C2.4-2.8c0-2.3-1.9-2.9-3.9-2.9h-3.5v9.8H26.4z        M26.4%2C60.3H28c1%2C0%2C2.1%2C0.1%2C2.1%2C1.3c0%2C1.3-1.2%2C1.4-2.3%2C1.4h-1.4V60.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M65.1%2C67c-0.2%2C0.1-0.6%2C0.2-0.8%2C0.2c-0.8%2C0-1-0.5-1-1.2V63h1.8v-1.5h-1.8v-1.6h-1.8v1.6h-1.3V63h1.3v3.2        c0%2C1.7%2C0.4%2C2.5%2C2.3%2C2.5c0.4%2C0%2C0.9-0.1%2C1.3-0.2V67z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M90.2%2C61.3c-0.1%2C0-0.3-0.1-0.5-0.1c-0.9%2C0-1.7%2C0.5-2.1%2C1.3h0v-1.1h-1.8v7h1.8v-3.8c0-0.4%2C0.2-1.8%2C1.9-1.8        c0.2%2C0%2C0.4%2C0%2C0.7%2C0.1V61.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M21%2C48.7c0%2C0-2%2C1-4%2C1.4l-6.4-39.9c-0.1-0.7-0.4-1.4-0.8-2l-2-2.9L7%2C9c-0.2%2C0.7-0.2%2C1.4-0.1%2C2.1l7%2C39.2        c-3.4-0.3-6.3-1.6-6.3-1.6c-1.1%2C3.2%2C0.8%2C5.1%2C0.8%2C5.1c4.5-1.6%2C8.4-1.8%2C12.9-1.6C21.4%2C52.2%2C22.1%2C50.3%2C21%2C48.7z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st2%22 d%3D%22M78.7%2C32.1c-0.1%2C0.2-0.9%2C2.4-16.6%2C8.6c-10.3%2C4.1-1.6%2C11.5-10.4%2C14.4c0.4-1.4%2C2-4.4-2.4-9.9        c-3-3.8-0.6-8.1%2C4.9-10.6c-4.9%2C1-8%2C3.9-11.7%2C5.5c-5.8%2C2.6-10.9%2C1.5-19.2%2C5.5c5.3-5%2C11.7-4%2C12.3-7.5c0.2-1.4%2C0.3-3.3%2C0.3-3.3        c-2.3%2C1.6-6%2C0.9-6.2-1.9c-3.7%2C0.3-6.6-5%2C0.4-9.7c0.1-0.1%2C0.5-2.9%2C0.7-4.8c0.8-7.8%2C7.5-10.9%2C11-9.2c2.4-1%2C4.3%2C0.7%2C4.8%2C2.1        c-1.7-1-8.8-3.1-8.6%2C5c2.1%2C1.2%2C3.8-2.5%2C4%2C3.5c0.1%2C1.4-0.6%2C2.8%2C2.7%2C2.3c0%2C0%2C0.1%2C0.6-0.4%2C1.3c-1.1%2C1.6%2C0.6%2C1.4%2C1.5%2C1.1        c0.3-0.1%2C0.7%2C1.2-0.9%2C2.2c-0.8%2C0.5-1.5%2C0.2-1.5%2C1.4c0%2C0.4%2C0.2%2C1.2%2C0.5%2C1.3c1%2C0.3%2C3.1-0.1%2C4.8-4c-0.1%2C4.6-3.2%2C5.5-3.6%2C6.4        c-0.2%2C0.5-0.3%2C1.2-0.3%2C2.3c0%2C0.9%2C0.5%2C1.8%2C2%2C1.2c9.3-3.6%2C12.8-2%2C23.1-4.9c0.6-1.7%2C1.6-3%2C2.5-4.2c0%2C0%2C7.3-7.4%2C9.5-16.5        c0.8-3.4%2C0.1-3.5%2C0.1-5.9c0-2.3%2C1.7-3.7%2C3-3.7c1.2%2C0%2C1.3%2C1.7%2C3.2%2C0.5c0%2C0%2C0%2C0%2C0%2C0c1%2C0.5%2C1.2%2C1.6%2C1.3%2C2.7c1.3-1.1%2C1.2-1.8%2C1.9-1.6        c0.9%2C0.3-0.3%2C2.3-0.9%2C3.3c-1.4%2C2.4-2.7%2C3.6-4%2C4.1C86.6%2C9.3%2C82.9%2C25%2C78.7%2C32.1z M39.1%2C23.5c1.9%2C0%2C1.6-4.6%2C1.6-5.4        c-0.2-2.3-5.1%2C0.1-4.5%2C1.5C36.7%2C20.9%2C37.8%2C23.5%2C39.1%2C23.5z M43.2%2C32.3c-3%2C1.1-0.8%2C3.2-2.7%2C5.9C41.9%2C37.3%2C43.4%2C37.6%2C43.2%2C32.3z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M30.1%2C23.1c0%2C0%2C4.2-3.2%2C8.9-3.8c1.7-0.2%2C2.6-0.6%2C3.1-1.1c0.2-0.2%2C1.5-1.2%2C1.9%2C0.1c0.4%2C1.2%2C0.7%2C1.9%2C1.7%2C1.9        c1.1%2C0.1%2C3.5-0.4%2C3.6%2C1.4c0%2C0%2C1.5-2.5-0.9-3.3c0%2C0%2C0.8-0.5%2C1-1.1c0%2C0-2.8-3.8-9.1-2.4c0-0.4%2C0.5-1.2%2C2.7-1.1c0%2C0-4.2-2.4-12.2%2C4.4        C30.7%2C18.2%2C30.4%2C20.9%2C30.1%2C23.1z%22%2F%3E    %3Cpath class%3D%22st1%22 d%3D%22M70.6%2C40.4c-2%2C0.1-3.9%2C0.3-5.7%2C0.7c1-2.3%2C5.8-16.1%2C7.5-21.8C71.9%2C23.3%2C70.7%2C35.7%2C70.6%2C40.4z M70.9%2C40.4        c0.5-2.8%2C1.8-11.9%2C2.6-21.1c0.2%2C0.8%2C5.5%2C15.4%2C8.6%2C22.1c-2.7-0.7-5.9-1-9.3-1C72.1%2C40.4%2C71.5%2C40.4%2C70.9%2C40.4z M100.3%2C18.9        c-0.4%2C1-5.5%2C16.4-6.9%2C22.3c-0.8%2C0.2-1.5%2C0.3-2.2%2C0.5c-0.2%2C0-0.2%2C0.2-0.1%2C0.4c2.2%2C2.7%2C6.1%2C4.4%2C10.5%2C4.4c4.4%2C0%2C8.3-1.8%2C10.5-4.4        c0.1-0.1%2C0.1-0.3-0.1-0.4c-0.2-0.1-0.5-0.1-0.7-0.2c-2.1-7.4-6.5-18.8-8-22.7c0.3%2C0%2C0.6-0.3%2C0.6-0.6v-0.4c0-0.3-0.3-0.6-0.6-0.6        H101c-3.6%2C0-4-3-7.8-3c-1.3%2C0-2.1%2C0.4-2.3%2C0.4c-0.2-1.3-1-2.3-2-2.8c1.6-0.6%2C2.7-2.1%2C2.9-3.9C92%2C6.2%2C91%2C4.6%2C89.6%2C3.8        c0%2C0.4-0.1%2C0.8-0.3%2C1.1c0.9%2C0.6%2C1.5%2C1.7%2C1.4%2C3c-0.1%2C1.8-1.7%2C3.2-3.5%2C3.1c-1.8-0.1-3.2-1.7-3.1-3.5c0.1-1.1%2C0.7-2.1%2C1.6-2.6        C85.5%2C4.5%2C85.3%2C4.2%2C85%2C4c-1.1%2C0.7-1.9%2C2-2%2C3.4c-0.1%2C2%2C1%2C3.7%2C2.8%2C4.4c-1.1%2C0.5-1.9%2C1.6-2%2C2.8c-0.2-0.1-1-0.4-2.3-0.4        c-3.7%2C0-4.2%2C3-7.8%2C3h-2.3c-0.3%2C0-0.6%2C0.3-0.6%2C0.6v0.4c0%2C0.3%2C0.3%2C0.6%2C0.6%2C0.6c0%2C0%2C0.1%2C0%2C0.1%2C0c-0.4%2C1-5.5%2C16.4-6.9%2C22.3        c-0.8%2C0.2-1.5%2C0.3-2.2%2C0.5c-0.2%2C0-0.2%2C0.2-0.1%2C0.4c2.2%2C2.7%2C6.1%2C4.4%2C10.5%2C4.4c4.4%2C0%2C8.3-1.8%2C10.5-4.4c0.1-0.1%2C0.1-0.3-0.1-0.4        c-0.2-0.1-0.5-0.1-0.7-0.2c-2.1-7.4-6.5-18.8-7.9-22.6c2.9%2C0%2C4.5-2.3%2C6.7-2.3c2.7%2C0%2C4%2C2.2%2C6.1%2C2.2c2.1%2C0%2C3.4-2.2%2C6.1-2.2        C95.7%2C16.6%2C97.3%2C19%2C100.3%2C18.9z M99.5%2C40.4c-2%2C0.1-3.9%2C0.3-5.7%2C0.7c1-2.3%2C5.8-16.1%2C7.5-21.8C100.8%2C23.3%2C99.6%2C35.7%2C99.5%2C40.4z        M99.8%2C40.4c0.5-2.8%2C1.8-11.9%2C2.6-21.1c0.2%2C0.8%2C5.5%2C15.4%2C8.6%2C22.1c-2.7-0.7-5.9-1-9.3-1C101%2C40.4%2C100.4%2C40.4%2C99.8%2C40.4z M88.6%2C15.1        c0%2C0.7-0.6%2C1.3-1.3%2C1.3c-0.7%2C0-1.3-0.6-1.3-1.3c0-0.7%2C0.6-1.3%2C1.3-1.3C88%2C13.8%2C88.6%2C14.4%2C88.6%2C15.1z%22%2F%3E%3C%2Fg%3E%3C%2Fsvg%3E" class="ms-siteicon-img" alt="Logo van de rechtspraak"> --> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl" title="Homepage Rechtspraak.nl"><span class="rs-logo-border"></span></a></div><p class="rs-skip-links"> <a class="rs-skip-link" href="#mainContent" title="Directly to search form">Direct to content</a> <a class="rs-skip-link" href="#mainNavigation" title="Directly to navigation menu">Direct to navigation menu</a></p><!-- div id="SearchBox" class="rs-search ms-srch-sb">
 +
            <input type="text" value="" name="" id="" title="Voer uw zoekterm in" class="" placeholder="Zoeken...">
 +
            <a href="javascript" title="Zoek" class="ms-srch-sb-searchLink"><img src="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/rs_header_search.png" alt="Rechtspraak.nl" width="14" height="15" /></a>
 +
        </div --></div><!--/.container --></div><!--/.rs-header --><!-- div id="titlearea">
 +
</div --><div class="toolbar"></div><!-- END HEADER --><div class="rs-main-contentarea" id="mainContent" data-target=".rs-main-contentarea"> <a class="rnl-button rnl-pagefeedbackform-button no-print" onclick="navigaToFeedbackForm();" href="javascript:undefined"><span>Feedback</span></a> <div class="rnl-content rnl-content-main"><div class="rnl-header-image-container"><div class="rnl-image-gradient"></div><img src="/SharedWebResources.axd?images/uitspraken-header-image-comp.jpg" alt="" /></div><div class="container"><div class="page-header rnl-page-header rnl-page-header-image"><div class="row"><div id="header" class="col-md-8"><h1> Pronunciations </h1></div></div><!--/.row --></div></div><div class="container"><div class="row"><div class="col-md-12"><div class="rs-panel zoektermen-wrapper"><div class="rs-panel-heading no-print"><h2> <a class="rs-accordion-title" data-toggle="collapse" href="#zoektermen" role="button" aria-expanded="true" aria-controls="zoektermen">Search terms found<span class="rs-collapse-icon-down"></span></a></h2></div><div class="row"><div class="col-md-12"> <label for="showhighlights" id="showhighlightslabel" class="label-highlights pull-left highlights-background"><input type="checkbox" id="showhighlights" name="showhighlights" checked><span id="markeringen-toggle-tekst">Turn markers off</span></label> </div></div><div class="collapse in rs-panel-body gevondenZoektermen no-print" id="zoektermen"><!-- --></div></div></div></div><div class="row opnieuw-zoeken-buttons"><div class="col-md-4"> <a href="/" class="rs-btn rs-btn-secondary search-btn-uitspraken" onclick="javascript:_paq.push(['trackEvent','uitspraken-pagina', 'button', 'opnieuw-zoeken']);">Search again</a></div><div class="col-md-4"> <a href="javascript:_paq.push(['trackEvent','uitspraken-pagina', 'button', 'terug-naar-resultaten']);history.back();" class="rs-btn rs-btn-primary search-btn-uitspraken">Back to the results</a></div></div><div class="row nieuwe-zoekopdracht-button"><div class="col-md-4"> <a href="/" class="rs-btn rs-btn-primary search-btn-uitspraken">New search</a> </div></div><div id="alert-region"><!-- --></div><div class="row"><div id="content" class="col-md-12"><div id="Main" class="rs-panel"><div class="rs-panel-heading rs-heading-inline"><h1 id="ZoekresultaatTekst" class="structural"> Search result - view document</h1><h2 class="left"> ECLI: NL: RBAMS: 2021: 174</h2><div class="btn-group rs-share rs-hide-mobile no-print"> <button class="rs-btn-secondary rs-btn dropdown-toggle" type="button" id="dropdownMenu1" data-toggle="dropdown" aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="true">Share pronunciation<span class="tri-down"></span></button><ul class="dropdown-menu rs-dropdown" aria-labelledby="dropdownMenu1"><li> <a href="javascript:window.print()" id="linkToPrint" class="printUitspraak" title="Print the document" onclick="javascript:_paq.push(['trackEvent','uitspraken-pagina', 'button', 'printen']);"><span>Print</span></a></li><li> <a class="pdfUitspraak no-print" href="/InzienDocument/GetPdf?ecli=ECLI%3ANL%3ARBAMS%3A2021%3A174" onclick="javascript:_paq.push([&#39;trackEvent&#39;,&#39;uitspraken-pagina&#39;, &#39;button&#39;, &#39;download-pdf&#39;]);">Save as PDF</a></li><li> <a href="javascript:undefined" id="copyUitspraak" class="no-print" data-clipboard-text="http://deeplink.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak?id=ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174" title="Copy link to statement" onclick="javascript:_paq.push(['trackEvent','uitspraken-pagina', 'button', 'kopieer']);"><span>Copy link</span></a></li></ul></div><div class="rs-copied-to-clipboard" id="clipboardInfo" style="display: none;"> Link copied to clipboard</div></div><div class="rs-panel-body"><dl class="dl-horizontal"><dt> Authority</dt><dd> <span>Court of Amsterdam</span></dd><dt> Date of judgment</dt><dd> 21-01-2021</dd><dt> Date of publication</dt><dd> 29-01-2021</dd><dt> Case number</dt><dd> <span>C / 13/694440 / KG ZA 20-1118</span><br /></dd><dt> Jurisdictions</dt><dd> <span>Civil rights</span><br /></dd><dt> Special characteristics</dt><dd> <span>First instance - single</span><br /> <span>Interim injunction</span><br /> <span>Interim ruling</span><br /></dd><dt> Content indication</dt><dd><div class="inhoudsindicatie"><p> summary proceedings, interlocutory judgment, preliminary questions, basis for BKR registration</p></div></dd><dt> Locations</dt><dd> <span>Rechtspraak.nl</span><br /></dd><dt class="no-print"></dt><dd class="no-print"> <a href="https://linkeddata.overheid.nl/document/ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174" id="linkToKoop" class="koopUitspraak" title="Enriched pronunciation"><span class="no-print">Enriched pronunciation</span></a></dd></dl><div class="btn-group rs-share rs-hide-desktop no-print"> <button class="rs-btn-secondary rs-btn dropdown-toggle" type="button" id="dropdownMenu1" data-toggle="dropdown" aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="true">Share pronunciation<span class="tri-down"></span></button><ul class="dropdown-menu rs-dropdown" aria-labelledby="dropdownMenu1"><li> <a href="javascript:printUitspraak()" id="linkToPrint" class="printUitspraak" title="Print the document" onclick="javascript:_paq.push(['trackEvent','uitspraken-pagina', 'button', 'printen']);"><span>Print</span></a></li><li> <a class="pdfUitspraak no-print" href="/InzienDocument/GetPdf?ecli=ECLI%3ANL%3ARBAMS%3A2021%3A174" onclick="javascript:_paq.push([&#39;trackEvent&#39;,&#39;uitspraken-pagina&#39;, &#39;button&#39;, &#39;download-pdf&#39;]);">Save as PDF</a></li><li> <a href="javascript:undefined" id="copyUitspraak" class="no-print" data-clipboard-text="http://deeplink.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak?id=ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174" title="Copy link to statement" onclick="javascript:_paq.push(['trackEvent','uitspraken-pagina', 'button', 'kopieer']);"><span>Copy link</span></a></li></ul></div><div class="uitspraakH3"><h3> Statement</h3></div><div><div class="uitspraak"><div class="uitspraak-info"><p> <span class="inlinemediaobject center"><span class="imageobject"><img src="/image/?id=0c70f504-9205-4069-8204-4cb446847d84" alt="" width="13" height="2" /></span></span> <span class="inlinemediaobject center"><span class="imageobject"><img src="/image/?id=989b7b1b-3315-4c65-8b0b-114077357f7e" alt="" width="523" height="2" /></span></span> verdict</p><h2 name="ID0EIB" style="font-weight:bold;" class="bridgehead"> COURT OF AMSTERDAM</h2><div class="parablock"><p> Private law department, civil relief judge</p></div><span class="linebreak2"> </span><div class="parablock"><p>case number / cause list number: C / 13/694440 / KG ZA 20-1118 MvW / JE</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="parablock"><p><span class="emphasis" style="font-weight:bold;">Interim injunction of 21 January 2021</span></p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="parablock"><p>in the case of</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="parablock"><p><span class="emphasis" style="font-weight:bold;">[claimant]</span> ,</p><p> residing in [residence],</p><p> plaintiff by summons of December 16, 2020,</p><p> lawyer mr. RH Bouwman in Amsterdam,</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="parablock"><p>against</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="parablock"><p>the legal person under Swedish law</p><p> <span class="emphasis" style="font-weight:bold;">HOIST FINANCE AB</span> ,</p><p> Located in Amsterdam,</p><p> defendant,</p><p> lawyer mr. HAP Pijnacker in Tilburg.</p></div><span class="linebreak2"> </span><div class="parablock"><p>The parties will hereinafter be referred to as [claimant] and Hoist Finance.</p></div><span class="linebreak2"> </span></div><div class="section"><h2><span class="nr">1</span> The procedure</h2><div class="parablock"><p> At the hearing of December 24, 2020, [claimant] explained the claim as described in the summons. Hoist Finance has put up a defense. Both parties have submitted written documents and Hoist Finance also submitted a pleading note.</p><p> The following were present at the hearing:</p></div><ul name="ID0EUE" class="mark"><li> <span class="mark">-</span><p> [claimant] with mr. Bouwman;</p></li><li> <span class="mark">-</span><p> on the side of Hoist Finance: mr. Pijnacker.</p></li></ul><div class="parablock"><p> At the hearing, the preliminary relief judge provisionally ruled that [plaintiff] is inadmissible in his claim and expressed the intention to ask the Supreme Court for a preliminary ruling on the basis of BKR registrations. The questions to be asked were formulated on the same date and sent to the parties by e-mail. Pursuant to article 392 paragraph 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Rv), the parties have been given the opportunity to comment on the intention to ask these questions, as well as on the content thereof. To this end, the case has been delayed until January 7, 2021. The lawyers of the parties responded to the intention in e-mails dated 29 December 2020 and 5 January 2021.</p><p> Mr. Pijnacker has taken the position that there is no need to refer questions for a preliminary ruling. Mr. Bouwman has announced that he can agree to ask preliminary questions, as formulated in draft by the preliminary relief judge. On January 11, 2021, mr. Bouwman reported that he wanted to propose an adjustment to the draft questions. Although submitted too late, mr. Bouwman&#39;s suggestion has been heeded. Verdict has been set to date.</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span></div><div class="section"><h2><span class="nr">2</span> The facts</h2><div class="paragroup"> <span class="nr">2.1.</span><p> At some point [claimant] has taken out a credit with (a legal predecessor of) Hoist Finance. Due to a subsequent payment arrears, Hoist Finance claimed the credit on July 5, 2006.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">2.2.</span><p> On May 8, 2006, [claimant] regarding the credit in the Central Credit Information System (hereinafter: the CKI) of the Credit Registration Office (hereinafter: the BKR) - a system in which payment arrears or other irregularities that arise during the term of a credit agreement with particularity codes are listed - under the name “[claimant]” with the particularity code “A”. This coding means that there is a backlog. On 28 June 2006, a 2-coding (together with the A-coding hereinafter: the BKR registration) was added to the listing in the CKI, which means that there is a claimed claim.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">2.3.</span><p> In a judgment of the District Court of Groningen dated 12 December 2006, [plaintiff] was ordered to pay € 5,000 to (a legal predecessor of) Hoist Finance, plus the agreed credit compensation on this amount from November 7, 2006 until the day of the general satisfaction.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">2.4.</span><p> [Claimant] has agreed a payment arrangement with NDA Incasso, to whom Hoist Finance had transferred the claim.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">2.5.</span><p> On June 1, 2017, a 3-coding was added to the BKR registration, which means that an amount greater than € 250 had to be debited from the credit.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">2.6.</span><p> In a letter dated 27 June 2017, NDA Incasso informed [claimant] that the entire claim had been paid.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">2.7.</span><p> On July 17, 2020, Hoist Finance notified [claimant] that it would have the 3-coding in the CKI of the BKR removed, following a request made by [claimant].<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">2.8.</span><p> On September 10, 2020, mr. Bouwman on behalf of [claimant] again submitted a request for removal of the BKR registration to Hoist Finance. Hoist Finance rejected this request by email dated September 21, 2020.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div></div><div class="section"><h2><span class="nr">3</span> The dispute</h2><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">3.1.</span><p> [Claimant] claims - in summary - to order Hoist Finance to have his BKR registration changed, in the sense that codes 2 and A will be removed after his name, with an order for Hoist Finance to pay the legal costs, plus interest. To this end, he states that he wants to buy a house, but that he cannot obtain a mortgage as a result of the registration. The deed of sale is scheduled to be passed on January 15, 2021. [Plaintiff] claims to be disproportionately disadvantaged by the registration. He points out that he has been debt-free for three years.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">3.2.</span><p> Hoist Finance argues against this - in short - that [plaintiff] responded too late to the negative decision of 21 September 2020 on his (second) removal request and is therefore inadmissible in his claim. Hoist Finance further disputes that [plaintiff] has an urgent interest in his claim. She also argues that the current registration will remain in place for five years, until June 1, 2022, and that [plaintiff] has not sufficiently substantiated why his interest in removal should outweigh the interest of maintaining the registration. The latter interest arises from the fact that there has been a bad financial situation at [plaintiff] for a long time. Lenders must therefore still be protected in this case.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div></div><div class="section overwegingen"><h2><span class="nr">4</span> The assessment</h2><div class="paragroup"> <span class="nr">4.1.</span><p> [claimant] exercised his right to object to his BKR registration on 10 September 2020. He has that right on the basis of Article 21 of the GDPR, the General Data Protection Regulation (Reg. (EU) 2016/679). Article 12 (3) of the GDPR means that in principle Hoist had to respond to the objection of [claimant] within one month. It did so on 21 September 2020. Article 35 paragraph 2 of the General Data Protection Regulation Implementation Act (UAVG) stipulates that [plaintiff] had to apply to the court within six weeks thereafter. He did not. That is why the preliminary relief judge provisionally ruled at the hearing that [plaintiff] is inadmissible in his claim.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.2.</span><p> If [claimant] were admissible, the claim would have to be assessed in substance. It follows from the procedural documents that both parties assume that codes 2 and A were correctly included in the CKI of the BKR at the time. In case law, there is uncertainty as to whether Hoist, as a participant in this system of credit registration, has thus complied with a legal obligation, so that the registration is in principle lawful as referred to in Article 6 paragraph 1 preamble and under c GDPR. The courts have ruled differently on this. The following judgments can be cited as the most recent examples.<span class="linebreak3"> </span></p><div class="parablock"><p><span class="emphasis" style="font-style:italic;">Den Bosch Court of Appeal 6 August 2020, ECLI: NL: GHSHE: 2020: 2536</span></p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.3.</span><p> The court held that the defendant bank is obliged by virtue of Section 4:32 of the Financial Supervision Act (Wft) to participate in a system of credit registration. In the Netherlands, that is the CKI, of which Stichting BKR is the implementer. The court ruled that the bank was allowed to process the personal data of the applicant pursuant to Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under c of the GDPR in order to fulfill its legal obligation. That is why the Court of Appeal did not get around to discussing the applicant&#39;s assertions based on Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under f (the balancing of interests), 17 paragraph 1 and 21 paragraph 1 GDPR.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.4.</span><p> The Court of Appeal&#39;s opinion is thus understood that the applicant has no right under the GDPR to object to the registration. This means that Article 35 paragraph 2 UAVG, which states that an application - or claim - can be lodged with a civil court within six weeks of the decision on the objection, does not apply. In that case, exceeding the term will not lead to inadmissibility.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p><div class="parablock"><p><span class="emphasis" style="font-style:italic;">Court of Appeal of The Hague 8 September 2020, ECLI: NL: GHDHA: 2020: 2068</span></p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.5.</span><p> The court ruled that article 6, paragraph 1, opening lines and under f GDPR, in any case provided a basis for the BKR registration. According to this court, it is not plausible that the registration is also necessary to comply with a legal obligation of the participating bank. According to the court, there is a legal obligation to participate in a system of credit registration, but not to perform a concrete registration in an individual case, nor to maintain data of the person concerned in the BKR system. That is why, according to this court, the registration does not also fall under Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under c GDPR. This means that the applicant has a right of objection under Article 21 (1) GDPR, but also that if that objection is rejected, he must bring the case to the civil court in a timely manner, within six weeks after the decision on the objection. . If this is not done in time, a non-admissibility must follow.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p><div class="parablock"><p><span class="emphasis" style="font-style:italic;">Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal December 17, 2020, ECLI: NL: GHARL: 2020: 10564</span></p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.6.</span><p> The court joins the court of Den Bosch and not the court of The Hague.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.7.</span><p> The following can also be noted here. If the basis of the obligation to process personal data in the present case were a &#39;legal obligation&#39; (Article 6, paragraph 1, opening words and under c of the GDPR), then the question is whether, as a defense against this, the right to be forgotten. (Article 17 GDPR) can be invoked. If this is not the case, the person who wishes to remove a registration can apply to the court, which must then apply the Santander assessment criterion (Supreme Court, 9 September 2011, ECLI: NL: HR: 2011: BQ8097). This is also the opinion of the Den Bosch Court of Appeal in the aforementioned judgment. It can be argued that this test is less favorable for those whose personal data have been processed (see the note of CEF van Waesberge in JOR 2020/10 at the Amsterdam District Court, 9 May 2019, ECLI: NL: RBAMS: 2019: 3857).<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.8.</span><p> The preliminary relief judge is of the opinion that the line of the court of The Hague must be followed. The legal obligation as referred to in Article 6, paragraph 1, opening words and under c of the GDPR, does not mean for banks that participate in the credit registration system of the BKR by virtue of Article 4:32 Wft, that every concrete registration must also be considered as&#39; necessary to comply with a legal obligation &#39;. The concrete registration is done for the implementation of the legal obligation, which implementation is based on the General Regulations CKI of the BKR. These regulations cannot be regarded as a &#39;legal&#39; regulation as referred to in Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under c GDPR.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.9.</span><p> This judgment means that the BKR registration of [claimant] can be tested against Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under f GDPR. But it also means, in the opinion of the preliminary relief judge, that [plaintiff] is too late with his claim and must be declared inadmissible (compare also the cited decision of the court of appeal in The Hague).<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.10.</span><p> Because the courts are divided, it is uncertain whether this preliminary judgment is correct. That is why the preliminary relief judge is of the opinion of its own motion that it is necessary to request the Supreme Court for a preliminary ruling that is important for the settlement or termination of numerous other disputes arising from similar facts, in which the same question arises (see article 392, paragraph 1, opening words). and under b, Rv). After all, cases in which it is requested or (in summary proceedings) claimed to have a BKR registration removed, occur frequently.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.11.</span><p> The registrar will be instructed to send the case file to the Supreme Court, simultaneously with this judgment.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">4.12.</span><p> After the answer of the Supreme Court has been received, the preliminary relief judge will give the parties the opportunity to comment on this in writing, after which a final judgment will be rendered.<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div></div><div class="section beslissing"><h2><span class="nr">5</span> The decision</h2><p> The preliminary relief judge<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">5.1.</span><p> the Supreme Court asks the following questions:<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p><div class="parablock"><p>1. Must the processing of concrete personal data by a credit institution, by means of an individual registration in the system of the BKR, be tested against the provisions of Article 6 paragraph 1, opening words and under c, GDPR, or against Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines? and under f GDPR, or both provisions?</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="parablock"><p>2. Means the answer to question 1</p><p> a.that the person whose personal data has been registered cannot invoke the right to erasure as referred to in Article 17 GDPR?</p><p> b. that the person has no right of objection as referred to in Article 21 GDPR?</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span><div class="parablock"><p>3. If the answer to question 2.b. means that there is no right to objection as referred to in Article 21 of the GDPR in the case of a BKR registration, does this mean that Article 35 of the UAVG does not play a role in the legal proceedings for the removal of that registration?</p></div><span class="linebreak1"> </span></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">5.2.</span><p> orders the registrar to forward the case file to the Supreme Court,<span class="linebreak1"> </span></p></div><div class="paragroup"><span class="nr">5.3.</span><p> suspends any further decision.<span class="linebreak2"> </span></p><div class="parablock"><p>This judgment was rendered by mr. M. van Walraven, preliminary relief judge, assisted by mr. JM Eisenhardt, registrar, and pronounced in public on January 21, 2021. <a class="noteref" href="#_5e246f77-b854-4107-8b9c-8686f52b58cf" title="type: JE coll: LO">1</a></p></div></div></div><div class="footnotes"><p> <span class="footnote" id="ID0E5HAC"><span class="note"><a name="_5e246f77-b854-4107-8b9c-8686f52b58cf">1</a></span> <span>type: JE</span> <span>coll: LO</span></span> </p></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="row no-print"><div id="contentZoneTop" class="col-md-12 no-print"></div></div></div><!--/.row --></div><!--/.container --><!--/.rnl-content --><div class="rnl-content no-print"><div class="container"><div id="contentZoneBottom"></div></div></div><!--/.rnl-content --><div id="rnl-breadcrumb-container"><div class="rnl-content"><div class="container"><ul class="rs-breadcrumb"><li> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl" title="Home">Home</a></li><li> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Uitspraken-en-nieuws" title="Statements and news">Statements and news</a></li></ul></div></div></div><div class="noteref-holder"> <button class="rs-btn rs-btn-primary noteref-back" type="button">Back to text<span class="tri-down tri-up"></span></button> </div></div><!--/.rs-main-contentarea --></div><!--/.rs-wrapper --><div class="rs-footer"><div class="container"><div class="row"><div class="rs-footer-general-section"><ul class="rs-footer-menu"><li> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/english/" title="">English</a></li><li> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/privacy" title="">Privacy</a></li><li> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/cookies" title="">Cookies</a> </li></ul></div><div class="rs-footer-social-section" data-tag="MegaMenu" data-view="footersocialmenu" data-template="footer-social-menu-template"> <span class="rs-footer-heading">follow us</span><ul class="rs-footer-menu"><li class="twitter"> <a class="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/rechtspraaknl">twitter</a></li><li class="facebook"> <a class="facebook" href="https://nl-nl.facebook.com/Rechtspraak">facebook</a></li><li class="linkedin"> <a class="linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/de-rechtspraak">linkedin</a></li><li class="youtube"> <a class="youtube" href="https://www.youtube.com/user/DeRechtspraak">youtube</a> </li></ul></div><div class="rs-footer-follow-section" data-tag="MegaMenu" data-view="footerfollowmenu" data-template="footer-follow-menu-template"> <span class="rs-footer-heading">Stay informed</span><ul class="rs-footer-menu"><li class="rss"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/rss" class="rss">rss</a></li><li class="email"> <a href="http://www.nieuwsbriefrechtspraak.nl/" class="email">e-mail</a> </li></ul></div></div><!--/.row --></div><!--/.container --></div><!--/.rs-footer --><script id="rnl-enquete-script" type="text/javascript" src="/SharedWebResources.axd?js/Rechtspraak/js/MWM2Popup.js"></script><script id="rnl-menu-script" type="text/javascript" src="/SharedWebResources.axd?js/Rechtspraak/js/rnlmenu.js"></script><!-- a href="#liquidcontent" class="skiplink">direct naar inhoud</a --><div class="navbar rs-navbar" role="navigation"><div class="container"><div class="row"><div class="navbar-header"> <button type="button" class="navbar-toggle rs-navbar-toggle collapsed" data-toggle="collapse" data-target=".navbar-collapse">Menu<span class="caret"></span></button> </div><div class="navbar-collapse collapse"><ul class="nav navbar-nav" id="mainNavigation" data-target=".navbar-collapse"><li class="dropdown "><a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/" title="Home" >Home</a></li><li class="dropdown rs-mega-menu"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen" title="subjects" >subjects</a><ul class="dropdown-menu rs-dropdown-menu"><li class="col-sm-6 htmlClassNoLink"><h3> Procedures</h3><ul><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Belastingen-toeslagen-en-uitkeringen.aspx" title="Taxes, Fees and Benefits" >Taxes, Fees and Benefits</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Consumenten.aspx" title="Consumers" >Consumers</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Familie-en-relaties.aspx" title="Family and relationships" >Family and relationships</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Gezondheid-en-zorg.aspx" title="Health and care" >Health and care</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Huis-en-omgeving.aspx" title="House and surroundings" >House and surroundings</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Maatregelen-en-straffen.aspx" title="Measures and punishments" >Measures and punishments</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Schade-en-aansprakelijkheid.aspx" title="Damage and Liability" >Damage and Liability</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Schulden-en-faillissement.aspx" title="Debts and bankruptcy" >Debts and bankruptcy</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Vreemdelingen.aspx" title="Aliens" >Aliens</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen/Paginas/Werk-inkomen-en-ondernemen.aspx" title="Work, income and entrepreneurship" >Work, income and entrepreneurship</a></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen" title="More procedures" >More procedures</a></li></ul></li><li class="col-sm-6 htmlClassNoLink"><h3> To court</h3><ul><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Naar-de-rechter" title="What to Expect" >What to Expect</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Naar-de-rechter/In-de-rechtszaal" title="The session" >The session</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Naar-de-rechter/Rechtszaak-starten" title="Start lawsuit" >Start lawsuit</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Naar-de-rechter/Hoger-beroep" title="Go in appeal" >Go in appeal</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Naar-de-rechter/Paginas/Advocaat-wel-of-niet-verplicht.aspx" title="Lawyer required or not" >Lawyer required or not</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Contact/Juridisch-advies" title="Legal advice" >Legal advice</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Naar-de-rechter/Kosten-rechtszaak" title="Costs of lawsuit" >Costs of lawsuit</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/begrippen" title="Concepts" >Concepts</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Naar-de-rechter/Checklist" title="Checklist - what to bring" >Checklist - what to bring</a></li></ul></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Onderwerpen" title="All procedures" >All procedures</a></li></ul></li><li class="dropdown rs-mega-menu rs-mega-menu-bold"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Uitspraken-en-nieuws" title="Statements and news" >Statements and news</a><ul class="dropdown-menu rs-dropdown-menu"><li class="col-sm-3 rs-cta-container"> <a href="https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/" title="Pronunciations" >Pronunciations</a></li><li class="col-sm-3 rs-news-item"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Nieuwsoverzicht" title="News overview" >News overview</a> <div class="rs-news-item-container"><img src="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/SiteCollectionImages/Wetboek%20van%20Strafvordering.JPG?width=50&amp;height=55" width="50" height="55" alt="News overview"> <span class="rs-news-item-header">News overview</span><div class="rs-news-item-text"> Stay up to date with the latest case law news and rulings.</div></div></li><li class="col-sm-3 rs-news-item"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Bekende-rechtszaken" title="Known lawsuits" >Known lawsuits</a> <div class="rs-news-item-container"><img src="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/SiteCollectionImages/In-de-rechtszaal.jpg?width=50&amp;height=55" width="50" height="55" alt="Known lawsuits"> <span class="rs-news-item-header">Known lawsuits</span><div class="rs-news-item-text"> On this special page you will find information about lawsuits that are receiving a lot of media attention. For example: Marengo, Pulheim, the appeal of Willem Holleeder and the case against Jos B.</div></div></li><li class="col-sm-3 rs-news-item"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Themas" title="Themes" >Themes</a> <div class="rs-news-item-container"><img src="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/SiteCollectionImages/tbs.jpg?width=50&amp;height=55" width="50" height="55" alt="Themes"> <span class="rs-news-item-header">Themes</span><div class="rs-news-item-text"> On this special page you will find further information on subjects that are closely related to the judiciary, such as tbs, life imprisonment, community service and remand.</div></div></li><li class="col-sm-3 rs-clear-left"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Persinformatie/Paginas/Rechtspraak-op-sociale-media.aspx" title="Justice on social media" >Justice on social media</a></li><li class="col-sm-3 rs-clear-left"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Persinformatie" title="For the press" >For the press</a></li></ul></li><li class="dropdown rs-mega-menu rs-mega-menu-col-9"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers" title="Registers" >Registers</a><ul class="dropdown-menu rs-dropdown-menu"><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://ccbr.rechtspraak.nl" title="Trustee and administration register" >Trustee and administration register</a><ul><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Gebruik-Centraal-Curatele-en-bewindregister.aspx" title="Frequently asked questions Central Trustee and administration register" >Frequently asked questions Central Trustee and administration register</a></li><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Hulp-bij-zoeken-CCBR.aspx" title="Help with finding CCBR" >Help with finding CCBR</a></li></ul></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://insolventies.rechtspraak.nl" title="Central insolvency register" >Central insolvency register</a><ul><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://insolventies.rechtspraak.nl/bekendmakingen.aspx" title="Insolvency Disclosures" >Insolvency Disclosures</a></li><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Termijnen-insolventies.aspx" title="Deadlines for insolvencies" >Deadlines for insolvencies</a></li><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Inhoudelijke-informatie-insolventies.aspx" title="Substantive information on insolvencies" >Substantive information on insolvencies</a></li><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Webservice-Centraal-Insolventieregister.aspx" title="Web service Central Insolvency Register" >Web service Central Insolvency Register</a></li><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Toelichting-insolventieregister.aspx" title="Explanation" >Explanation</a></li><li class="hidden"><a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/EU-registratie.aspx" title="EU registration" >EU registration</a></li></ul></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/centraal-register-voor-collectieve-vorderingen" title="Central register for collective actions" >Central register for collective actions</a></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Registratie-van-persoonsgegevens" title="Registration of personal data" >Registration of personal data</a></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://hgr.rechtspraak.nl" title="Matrimonial property register" >Matrimonial property register</a><ul><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Hulp-bij-zoeken-Huwelijksgoederenregister.aspx" title="Help with finding the Marriage Property Register" >Help with finding the Marriage Property Register</a></li><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Toelichting-Huwelijksgoederenregister.aspx" title="Explanation of Marriage Property Register" >Explanation of Marriage Property Register</a></li></ul></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://namenlijst.rechtspraak.nl" title="Ancillary positions of judges" >Ancillary positions of judges</a><ul><li class="hidden"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Leidraad-onpartijdigheid-en-nevenfuncties-van-de-rechter.aspx" title="Guidelines on impartiality and ancillary positions of the judge" >Guidelines on impartiality and ancillary positions of the judge</a></li></ul></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Gezagsregister" title="Authority register" >Authority register</a></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Paginas/Boedelregister.aspx" title="Property register" >Property register</a></li><li class="col-sm-4"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Registers/Zaakverloopregister" title="Case history register" >Case history register</a></li></ul></li><li class="dropdown rs-mega-menu rs-mega-menu-col-9"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact" title="the Judiciary" >the Judiciary</a><ul class="dropdown-menu rs-dropdown-menu"><li class="col-sm-8"> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie" title="Organization" >Organization</a><ul><li class="rs-mega-menu"><a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Rechtbanken" title="Courts" >Courts</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Gerechtshoven" title="Courts of Justice" >Courts of Justice</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Hoge-Raad-der-Nederlanden" title="Supreme Court of the Netherlands" >Supreme Court of the Netherlands</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Centrale-Raad-van-beroep" title="Central Board of Appeal" >Central Board of Appeal</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/College-van-Beroep-voor-het-bedrijfsleven" title="Board of Appeals for Business" >Board of Appeals for Business</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Raad-van-State" title="Council of State" >Council of State</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Raad-voor-de-rechtspraak" title="Council for the Judiciary" >Council for the Judiciary</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Landelijke-diensten" title="Rural services" >Rural services</a></li><li class=""> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Werken-en-opleiding" title="Work and training" >Work and training</a></li></ul></li></ul></li><li class="dropdown "> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Voor-advocaten-en-juristen" title="Professionals" >Professionals</a></li><li class="dropdown "> <a href="https://www.rechtspraak.nl/Organisatie-en-contact/Contact" title="Contact" >Contact</a></li><li class="dropdown rs-mijn-zaak"> <a href="https://mijn.rechtspraak.nl" title="Forms and login" >Forms and login</a> </li></ul></div><!--/.nav-collapse --></div><!--/.row --></div><!--/.container --></div><!--/.navbar --><script type="text/javascript">window.NpiSettings = {"DeepLink":"http://deeplink.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak?id=ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174","Keywords":null};</script><script type="text/javascript" data-main="/Scripts/main-inziendocument.js" src="/Scripts/libs/require/require.js"></script><script type="text/javascript">
  
verdict
+
        $(window).load(function(){
COURT OF AMSTERDAM
+
            if(typeof(_paq) != 'undefined'){
  
Private law department, civil relief judge
+
                //Piwik site Id's
 +
                var rechtBankList = {
 +
                    "Rechtbank Amsterdam": 17,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Den Haag": 19,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Gelderland": 21,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Limburg": 23,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Midden-Nederland": 25,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Noord-Holland": 27,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Noord-Nederland": 29,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Oost-Brabant": 31,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Overijssel": 33,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Rotterdam": 35,
 +
                    "Rechtbank Zeeland-West-Brabant": 37,
 +
                    "Gerechtshof Amsterdam": 53,
 +
                    "Gerechtshof Leeuwarden": 55,
 +
                    "Gerechtshof Arnhem": 55,
 +
                    "Gerechtshof Den Haag": 57,
 +
                    "Gerechtshof &#39;s-Hertogenbosch": 59
 +
                };
  
case number / cause list number: C / 13/694440 / KG ZA 20-1118 MvW / JE
+
                var instantieNaam='Rechtbank Amsterdam';
 +
                if (rechtBankList[instantieNaam] != null)
 +
                {
 +
                    var u = 'https://statistiek.rechtspraak.nl/';
 +
                    _paq.push(['addTracker', piwikUrl = u+'piwik.php', rechtBankList[instantieNaam]]);
 +
                }
  
Interim injunction of 21 January 2021
+
                //Piwik
 +
                _paq.push(['setCustomUrl', "UitspraakDetailView/ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2021:174"]);
 +
                _paq.push(['trackPageView', "UIT " + document.title]);
 +
            }
  
in the case of
 
  
[claimant] ,
+
        });
 +
    </script><script type="text/javascript">
 +
                (function (window, document, dataLayerName, id) {
 +
                window[dataLayerName] = window[dataLayerName] || [], window[dataLayerName].push({ start: (new Date).getTime(), event: "stg.start" });
 +
                    var scripts = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0], tags = document.createElement('script');
 +
                    function stgCreateCookie(a, b, c) { var d = ""; if (c) { var e = new Date; e.setTime(e.getTime() + 24 * c * 60 * 60 * 1e3), d = "; expires=" + e.toUTCString() } document.cookie = a + "=" + b + d + "; path=/" }
 +
                    var isStgDebug = (window.location.href.match("stg_debug") || document.cookie.match("stg_debug")) && !window.location.href.match("stg_disable_debug"); stgCreateCookie("stg_debug", isStgDebug ? 1 : "", isStgDebug ? 14 : -1);
 +
                    var qP = []; dataLayerName !== "dataLayer" && qP.push("data_layer_name=" + dataLayerName), isStgDebug && qP.push("stg_debug");
 +
                    var qPString = qP.length > 0 ? ("?" + qP.join("&")) : ""; tags.async = !0, tags.src = "https://statistiek.rechtspraak.nl/containers/" + id + ".js" + qPString, scripts.parentNode.insertBefore(tags, scripts); !function (a, n, i) { a[n] = a[n] || {}; for (var c = 0; c < i.length; c++)!function (i) { a[n][i] = a[n][i] || {}, a[n][i].api = a[n][i].api || function () { var a = [].slice.call(arguments, 0); "string" == typeof a[0] && window[dataLayerName].push({ event: n + "." + i + ":" + a[0], parameters: [].slice.call(arguments, 1) }) } }(i[c]) }(window, "ppms", ["tm", "cm"]);
 +
                })(window, document, 'dataLayer', '11b7c5ed-2b4c-406d-9d93-8e2bcf98a2dd');
 +
            </script><noscript><iframe src="https://statistiek.rechtspraak.nl/containers/11b7c5ed-2b4c-406d-9d93-8e2bcf98a2dd/noscript.html" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript><script type="text/javascript">
 +
        var rootWebAddress = "https://www.rechtspraak.nl";
 +
        var uitspraakContentPage = "/Blocks/Uitspraken.detail.xml";
 +
        var navigaToFeedbackForm = function () {
 +
            window.location.href = rootWebAddress + '/Paginas/Feedback.aspx?a=Uitspraken&u=' + window.location.href;
 +
        };
 +
        </script><script>
 +
            (function fillInzienContent() {
 +
                var contentLoader = {
 +
                    url: "",
  
residing in [residence],
+
                    load: function () {
 +
                        $.ajax(
 +
                            {
 +
                                url: this.url,
 +
                                method: "GET",
 +
                                dataType: "xml",
 +
                                global: false,
 +
                                success: this.onSuccess,
 +
                                error: this.onError
 +
                            }
 +
                        );
 +
                    },
 +
                    onSuccess: function (data) {
 +
                        var htmlTop = "";
 +
                        var htmlBottom = "";
 +
                        var publishingPagecontent = data.getElementsByTagNameNS("*", "PublishingPageContent")
 +
                        for (var i = 0; i < publishingPagecontent.length; i++) {
 +
                            htmlTop += publishingPagecontent[i].textContent;
 +
                        }
 +
                        var publishingMiddleContent = data.getElementsByTagNameNS("*", "Rnl_PageMiddleContent")
 +
                        for (var i = 0; i < publishingMiddleContent.length; i++) {
 +
                            htmlBottom += publishingMiddleContent[i].textContent;
 +
                        }
  
plaintiff by summons of December 16, 2020,
+
                                        htmlTop = htmlTop.replace(/href=\"\//gi, "href=\"" + window.rootWebAddress + "/");
 
+
                        htmlBottom = htmlBottom.replace(/href=\"\//gi, "href=\"" + window.rootWebAddress + "/");
lawyer mr. RH Bouwman in Amsterdam,
+
                        $("#contentZoneTop").html(htmlTop);
 
+
                        $("#contentZoneBottom").html(htmlBottom);
against
+
                    },
 
+
                    onError: function (request, status, error) {
the legal person under Swedish law
+
                        console.error(error);
 
+
                    }
HOIST FINANCE AB ,
+
                };
 
+
                contentLoader.url = window.uitspraakContentPage;
Located in Amsterdam,
+
                contentLoader.load();
 
+
            })();
defendant,
+
        </script></body></html>
 
 
attorney mr. HAP Pijnacker in Tilburg.
 
 
 
The parties will hereinafter be referred to as [claimant] and Hoist Finance.
 
1 The procedure
 
 
 
At the hearing of December 24, 2020, [claimant] explained the claim as described in the summons. Hoist Finance has put up a defense. Both parties have submitted written documents and Hoist Finance also submitted a pleading note.
 
 
 
The following were present at the hearing:
 
 
 
    -
 
 
 
    [plaintiff] with mr. Bouwman;
 
    -
 
 
 
    on the side of Hoist Finance: mr. Pijnacker.
 
 
 
At the hearing, the preliminary relief judge provisionally ruled that [plaintiff] is inadmissible in his claim and expressed the intention to ask the Supreme Court for a preliminary ruling on the basis of BKR registrations. The questions to be asked were formulated on the same date and sent to the parties by e-mail. In accordance with article 392 paragraph 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Rv), the parties have been given the opportunity to comment on the intention to ask these questions, as well as the content thereof. To this end, the case has been stayed until January 7, 2021. The parties' attorneys responded to the intention in emails dated 29 December 2020 and 5 January 2021.
 
 
 
Mr. Pijnacker has taken the position that there is no need to refer questions for a preliminary ruling. Mr. Bouwman has reported that he can agree to ask preliminary questions, as formulated in draft by the preliminary relief judge. On January 11, 2021, mr. Bouwman reported that he wanted to propose an adjustment to the draft questions. Although submitted too late, mr. Bouwman's suggestion has been heeded. Verdict has been set to date.
 
2 The facts
 
2.1.
 
 
 
At some point [claimant] has taken out a credit with (a legal predecessor of) Hoist Finance. Due to a subsequent payment arrears, Hoist Finance claimed the credit on July 5, 2006.
 
2.2.
 
 
 
On 8 May 2006, [plaintiff] is with regard to the credit in the Central Credit Information System (hereinafter: the CKI) of the Credit Registration Office (hereinafter: the BKR) - a system in which payment arrears or other irregularities that arise during the term of a credit agreement with particularity codes are listed - under the name “[claimant]” with the particularity code “A”. This coding means that there is a backlog. On 28 June 2006, a 2-coding (together with the A-coding hereinafter: the BKR registration) was added to the listing in the CKI, which means that there is a claimed claim.
 
2.3.
 
 
 
In a judgment of the District Court of Groningen of December 12, 2006, [plaintiff] was ordered to pay (a legal predecessor of) Hoist Finance of € 5,000, plus the agreed credit compensation on this amount from November 7, 2006 until the day of the general satisfaction.
 
2.4.
 
 
 
[Claimant] has agreed a payment arrangement with NDA Incasso, to whom Hoist Finance had transferred the claim.
 
2.5.
 
 
 
On June 1, 2017, a 3-coding was added to the BKR registration, which means that an amount greater than € 250 had to be debited from the credit.
 
2.6.
 
 
 
In a letter dated 27 June 2017, NDA Incasso informed [claimant] that the entire claim had been paid.
 
2.7.
 
 
 
On July 17, 2020, Hoist Finance informed [claimant] that it would have the 3-coding in the CKI of the BKR removed, following a request made by [claimant].
 
2.8.
 
 
 
On September 10, 2020, mr. Bouwman on behalf of [claimant] again submitted a request for removal of the BKR registration to Hoist Finance. Hoist Finance rejected this request by email dated September 21, 2020.
 
3 The dispute
 
3.1.
 
 
 
[plaintiff] claims - in summary - to order Hoist Finance to have his BKR registration changed, in the sense that codes 2 and A will be removed after his name, with an order for Hoist Finance to pay the costs of the proceedings, plus interest. To this end, he states that he wants to buy a house, but that he cannot obtain a mortgage as a result of the registration. The deed of sale is scheduled to be executed on January 15, 2021. [Plaintiff] states that the registration will be disproportionately disadvantageous. He points out that he has been debt-free for three years.
 
3.2.
 
 
 
Hoist Finance argues against this - in short - that [plaintiff] responded too late to the negative decision of 21 September 2020 on his (second) removal request and is therefore inadmissible in his claim. Hoist Finance further disputes that [plaintiff] has an urgent interest in his claim. She also argues that the current registration will remain in place for five years, until June 1, 2022, and that [plaintiff] has not sufficiently substantiated why his interest in removal should outweigh the interest of maintaining the registration. The latter interest arises from the fact that there has been a bad financial situation at [plaintiff] for a longer period of time. Lenders must therefore still be protected in this case.
 
4 The assessment
 
4.1.
 
 
 
[Claimant] exercised his right to object to his BKR registration on 10 September 2020. He has that right on the basis of Article 21 of the GDPR, the General Data Protection Regulation (Reg. (EU) 2016/679). Article 12 (3) of the GDPR means that in principle Hoist had to respond to the objection of [claimant] within one month. It did so on 21 September 2020. Article 35 paragraph 2 of the General Data Protection Regulation Implementation Act (UAVG) stipulates that [plaintiff] had to apply to the court within six weeks thereafter. He did not. That is why the preliminary relief judge has provisionally ruled at the hearing that [plaintiff] is inadmissible in his claim.
 
4.2.
 
 
 
If [plaintiff] were admissible, the claim would have to be assessed in substance. It follows from the procedural documents that both parties assume that codes 2 and A were correctly included in the CKI of the BKR at the time. In case law, there is uncertainty as to whether Hoist, as a participant in this credit registration system, has thus complied with a statutory obligation, so that the registration is in principle lawful as referred to in Article 6 paragraph 1 preamble and under c of the GDPR. The courts of appeal have ruled differently on this. The following judgments can be cited as the most recent examples.
 
 
 
Den Bosch Court of Appeal 6 August 2020, ECLI: NL: GHSHE: 2020: 2536
 
4.3.
 
 
 
The court held that the defendant bank is obliged under Section 4:32 of the Financial Supervision Act (Wft) to participate in a system of credit registration. In the Netherlands, that is the CKI, of which Stichting BKR is the implementer. The court ruled that the bank was allowed to process the personal data of the petitioner pursuant to Article 6, paragraph 1, opening words and under c of the GDPR in order to fulfill its legal obligation. That is why the Court of Appeal did not get around to discussing the applicant's assertions based on Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under f (the balancing of interests), 17 paragraph 1 and 21 paragraph 1 GDPR.
 
4.4.
 
 
 
The judgment of the court is thus understood that the applicant has no right under the GDPR to object to the registration. This means that Article 35 paragraph 2 UAVG, which states that an application - or claim - can be lodged with a civil court within six weeks of the decision on the objection, does not apply. If the term is exceeded, this will not result in inadmissibility.
 
 
 
Court of Appeal of The Hague 8 September 2020, ECLI: NL: GHDHA: 2020: 2068
 
4.5.
 
 
 
The court ruled that article 6, paragraph 1, opening lines and under f GDPR, in any case provided a basis for the BKR registration. According to this court, it is unlikely that the registration is also necessary to comply with a legal obligation of the participating bank. According to the court of appeal, there is a legal obligation to participate in a system of credit registration, but not to perform a concrete registration in an individual case, nor to maintain data of the person concerned in the system of the BKR. That is why, according to this court, the registration does not also fall under Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under c GDPR. This means that the applicant has the right to object on the basis of Article 21 (1) GDPR, but also that, if that objection is rejected, he / she will be notified in good time, within six weeks of the decision on the objection,should bring the case to a civil court. If this is not done in time, an inadmissibility must follow.
 
 
 
Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal December 17, 2020, ECLI: NL: GHARL: 2020: 10564
 
4.6.
 
 
 
The court joins the court of Den Bosch and not the court of The Hague.
 
4.7.
 
 
 
The following can also be noted here. If the basis of the obligation to process personal data in the present case were a 'legal obligation' (Article 6, paragraph 1, opening words and under c GDPR), then the question is whether, as a defense against this, the right to be forgotten. (Article 17 GDPR) can be invoked. If this is not the case, the person who wishes to remove a registration can apply to a court, which must then apply the Santander assessment criterion (Supreme Court, 9 September 2011, ECLI: NL: HR: 2011: BQ8097). The Den Bosch Court of Appeal also ruled in the above judgment. It can be argued that this test is less favorable for those whose personal data have been processed (see the note of CEF van Waesberge in JOR 2020/10 at the Amsterdam District Court, 9 May 2019, ECLI: NL: RBAMS: 2019: 3857).
 
4.8.
 
 
 
The preliminary relief judge is of the opinion that the line of the Court of Appeal of The Hague must be followed. The legal obligation as referred to in Article 6, paragraph 1, opening words and under c of the GDPR does not mean for banks that participate in the credit registration system of the BKR by virtue of Article 4:32 Wft, that every concrete registration must also be considered as' necessary to comply with a legal obligation '. The concrete registration is done for the implementation of the legal obligation, which implementation is based on the General Regulations CKI of the BKR. These regulations cannot be regarded as a 'legal' regulation as referred to in Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under c GDPR.
 
4.9.
 
 
 
This judgment means that the BKR registration of [claimant] can be tested against Article 6 paragraph 1 opening lines and under f GDPR. But it also means, in the opinion of the preliminary relief judge, that [plaintiff] is too late with his claim and must be declared inadmissible (compare also the cited decision of the court of appeal in The Hague).
 
4.10.
 
 
 
Because the courts are divided, it is uncertain whether this provisional judgment is correct. That is why the Preliminary Relief Judge of its own motion is of the opinion that it is necessary to request the Supreme Court for a preliminary ruling that is important for the settlement or termination of numerous other disputes arising from similar facts, in which the same question arises (see article 392, paragraph 1, opening words). and under b, Rv). After all, cases in which it is requested or (in summary proceedings) claimed to have a BKR registration removed, occur frequently.
 
4.11.
 
 
 
The registrar will be instructed to send the case file to the Supreme Court, simultaneously with this judgment.
 
4.12.
 
 
 
After the answer of the Supreme Court has been received, the preliminary relief judge will give the parties the opportunity to comment on this in writing, after which a final judgment will be rendered.
 
5 The decision
 
 
 
The preliminary relief judge
 
5.1.
 
 
 
the Supreme Court asks the following questions:
 
 
 
1. Must the processing of concrete personal data by a credit institution, by means of an individual registration in the BKR system, be assessed against the provisions of Article 6, paragraph 1, opening words and under c, GDPR, or against Article 6, paragraph 1, opening words? and under f GDPR, or both provisions?
 
 
 
2. Means the answer to question 1
 
 
 
a.that the person whose personal data has been registered cannot invoke the right to erasure as referred to in Article 17 GDPR?
 
 
 
b. that the person has no right of objection as referred to in Article 21 GDPR?
 
 
 
3. If the answer to question 2.b. means that there is no right to objection as referred to in Article 21 of the GDPR in the case of a BKR registration, does this mean that Article 35 of the UAVG does not play a role in the legal proceedings for the removal of that registration?
 
5.2.
 
 
 
orders the registrar to forward the case file to the Supreme Court,
 
5.3.
 
 
 
suspends any further decision.
 
 
 
This judgment was rendered by mr. M. van Walraven, preliminary relief judge, assisted by mr. JM Eisenhardt, registrar, and pronounced in public on January 21, 2021. 1
 
 
</pre>
 
</pre>

Please note that all contributions to GDPRhub are considered to be released under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike (see GDPRhub:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To edit this page, please answer the question that appears below (more info):

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)

Template used on this page: